★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
Of Subsidiary Punishments</head> | Of Subsidiary Punishments</head> | ||
<p><add>Rule 3<hi rend="superscript">d</hi></add> <hi rend="underline">When the cause of failure may be want of power</hi><lb/> | <p><add>Rule 3<hi rend="superscript">d</hi></add> <hi rend="underline">When the cause of failure may be want of power</hi><lb/> | ||
<hi rend="underline">or want of will as it may happen</hi><add>and it <del>is</del | <hi rend="underline">or want of will as it may happen</hi><add><hi rend="underline">and it <del>is</del> cannot be known which</hi></add>, <hi rend="underline">the subsidiary</hi><lb/> | ||
<hi rend="underline">punishment ought to be greater than the punishment</hi><lb/> | <hi rend="underline">punishment ought to be greater than the punishment</hi><lb/> | ||
first-designed, but not so much greater as in the<lb/> | |||
<del>second case</del><add>case last mentioned.</add> This is <add>apt to be</add> the case with pecuniary Forfeitures.<lb/> | <del>second case</del><add>case last mentioned.</add> This is <add>apt to be</add> the case with pecuniary Forfeitures.<lb/> | ||
If however it can be ascertained which of<lb/> | If however it can be ascertained which of<lb/> | ||
these | these is the cause, it ought always to be done: otherwise<lb/> | ||
on the <del><gap/></del> one hand he who fails from<lb/> | on the <del><gap/></del> one hand he who fails from<lb/> | ||
mere inability <del>may</del><add>will</add> be punished more than there<lb/> | mere inability <del>may</del><add>will</add> be punished more than there<lb/> | ||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
punishment first-designed for him, such a failure <lb/> | punishment first-designed for him, such a failure <lb/> | ||
may be cconsider'd in the light of an offence.<lb/> | may be cconsider'd in the light of an offence.<lb/> | ||
Viewing it <hi rend="underline">in</hi> this light | Viewing it <hi rend="underline">in</hi> this light we shall immediately.<lb/> | ||
see the propriety of the following rule I</p> | see the propriety of the following rule I</p> | ||
<p>Rule 4 <del>that</del> <hi rend="underline">The subsidiary punishment ought to</hi><lb/> | <p>Rule 4 <del>that</del> <hi rend="underline">The subsidiary punishment ought to</hi><lb/> | ||
<hi rend="underline">be made the greater, the</hi> <del><gap/></del> <del>[more difficult it is</del><lb/> | <hi rend="underline">be made the greater, the</hi> <del><gap/></del> <del>[more difficult it is</del><lb/> | ||
<del>for the failure</del> <add><hi rend="underline">defalter</hi></add> <del>to be detected and made amenable</del>]<lb/> | <del>for the failure</del> <add><hi rend="underline">defalter</hi></add> <del>to be detected and made amenable</del>]<lb/> | ||
<hi rend="underline">easier it is for the delinquent to</hi> <del>[make default]</del><add><del>[withdraw himself</del> </add> <del>< | <hi rend="underline">easier it is for the delinquent to</hi> <del>[make default]</del><add><del>[withdraw himself</del> </add> <del>avoid</del><lb/> | ||
<hi rend="underline"> | <hi rend="underline"><del>from]</del><add>avoid</add> the punishment first-designed [without being</hi><lb/> | ||
to be efficacious must always be greater than <del>profit</del><add>temptation | <hi rend="underline">detected and made amenable</hi>.] For the punishment<lb/> | ||
the offence: and the temptation to the offence<lb/> | to be efficacious must always be greater than <del>profit</del><add>temptation </add><lb/> | ||
<del>of</del><add>to</add> the offence: and the temptation to the offence<lb/> | |||
is the greater, the greater is the uncertainty of that<lb/> | is the greater, the greater is the uncertainty of that<lb/> | ||
punishment which is the motive that <del> | punishment which is the motive that <del>stands in</del><add><del>in</del></add> <del><sic>ballance</sic></del><lb/> | ||
<add>weighs</add> against the profit of the offence.</p><pb/> | <add>weighs</add> against the profit of the offence.</p><pb/> | ||
Click Here To Edit Of Subsidiary Punishments
Rule 3d When the cause of failure may be want of power
or want of will as it may happenand it is cannot be known which, the subsidiary
punishment ought to be greater than the punishment
first-designed, but not so much greater as in the
second casecase last mentioned. This is apt to be the case with pecuniary Forfeitures.
If however it can be ascertained which of
these is the cause, it ought always to be done: otherwise
on the one hand he who fails from
mere inability maywill be punished more than there
is occasion, and he who fails wilfully makes default from want of will inclination
not enough.
When a man fails wilfully to submitt to the
punishment first-designed for him, such a failure
may be cconsider'd in the light of an offence.
Viewing it in this light we shall immediately.
see the propriety of the following rule I
Rule 4 that The subsidiary punishment ought to
be made the greater, the [more difficult it is
for the failure defalter to be detected and made amenable]
easier it is for the delinquent to [make default][withdraw himself avoid
from]avoid the punishment first-designed [without being
detected and made amenable.] For the punishment
to be efficacious must always be greater than profittemptation
ofto the offence: and the temptation to the offence
is the greater, the greater is the uncertainty of that
punishment which is the motive that stands inin ballance
weighs against the profit of the offence.
---page break---
|
Identifier: | JB/141/132/004"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 141. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
141 |
rationale of punishment |
||
|
132 |
book 6 ch. 2 of subsidiary punishments |
||
|
004 |
|||
|
text sheet |
4 |
||
|
recto |
f1 / f2 / f3 / f4 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::l v g propatria [britannia motif]]] |
||
|
caroline vernon |
|||
|
48349 |
|||
