JB/038/280/001: Difference between revisions

Transcribe Bentham: A Collaborative Initiative

From Transcribe Bentham: Transcription Desk

Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts

JB/038/280/001: Difference between revisions

Jancopes (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
BenthamBot (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE -->


<note>B Feb<hi rend="superscript">y</hi>Supersedes after Apr. 5 by a<lb/>first Draught</note><lb/>1826. Feb<hi rend="superscript">y.</hi> 3<lb/><head>Constitutional Code.</head><p>Ch. VI. Legislative.<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale</p><p>1.<lb/>Quest 1. Non-relocability,<lb/>why<lb/>Ans. 1. From undiscontinued<lb/>relocability,<lb/>evil in all shapes:<lb/>good in none.</p><p>2.<lb/>2. to public, all good<lb/>expected from it is secured<lb/>by Continuation Committee<lb/>with addition,<lb/>and without evil.</p><p>3.<lb/>3. To public, the evil<lb/>has for immediate cause<lb/>relative inaptitude in<lb/>all shapes.</p><p>4.<lb/>4. To deputies, evil<lb/>none; because<lb/>disappointment none: those<lb/>whom the Constitution<lb/>finds located excepted:<lb/>whence the grand<lb/>obstruction.</p><p>5.<lb/>5. Of the evil immediate<lb/>cause, relative<lb/>inaptitude in all shapes<lb/><del>6.</del><lb/><del>6. <gap/></del> taken together:<lb/>for, by relocability<lb/>the first location is<lb/>made tantamount<lb/>to d<hi rend="superscript">o.</hi> for life:<lb/>non-relocation, <add>to</add> dislocation.<lb/>The first locatee pleads<lb/>appropriate services:<lb/>neither now nor ever can<lb/><del>now or ever can be</del><lb/>locatee plead any: by<lb/>no negative inaptitude<lb/>can a man be ousted:<lb/>only by flagrant<lb/>positive. Thus, the first<lb/>year; by every other, the<lb/>hold is strengthened.</p><pb/>Ch. VI. Legislative.<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale<p><del>6</del>7.<lb/>7. Next are moral in<lb/>particular. All will<lb/>be corrupted. Ordinary<lb/>price that of the mutes:<lb/>higher &amp; higher those of<lb/>the speakers &amp; managers.</p><p>8.<lb/>Corruptors, the Prime<lb/>Justice Minister, chief<lb/>givers of good gifts &#x2014;<lb/>2. Leading Electors.<lb/>-----<lb/>II. 6 8.<lb/>9. Matter, by expectation of<lb/>which, deputies will be<lb/>corrupted. Offices for their<lb/>connections.</p><p>9.<lb/>10. Matter, expectation of<lb/>which Ministers will be<lb/>corrupted by, expectation<lb/>of power and emolument<lb/><sic>encreased</sic>, responsibility<lb/>diminished.</p><p>11.<lb/>11. Matter, by expectation<lb/>of which, leading Electors<lb/>will be corrupted by<lb/>services rendered to them<lb/>in their individual<lb/>capacity.<lb/>1. Minor good gifts thro'<lb/>Ministers.<lb/>2. Personal courtesy and<lb/>flattery towards themselves.<lb/>-----</p><p>11 <del>12.</del><lb/>12. In both cases, corruption<lb/>safe, <hi rend="underline">no statement</hi><lb/><hi rend="underline">of terms</hi> &#x2014; no <hi rend="underline">bargains</hi><lb/>being necessary: no<lb/>exposure to punishment<lb/>or shame.</p><pb/><note>§. 1. From undiscontinued<lb/>relocability d<hi rend="superscript">o</hi> corrupted: observe<lb/>evil <gap/> <gap/> in all<lb/>shapes, 2. in moral : 1 L 7<lb/>§. 2. Matter of corruption 8. 4 15<lb/>§. 3. <hi rend="underline">Experience</hi> <gap/>146</note><lb/>Ch. VI. Legislative.<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale<p>12.<lb/>13. In the moral, attraction<lb/>of corruption is<lb/>what d<hi rend="superscript">o.</hi> of gravity is<lb/>in the physical world.</p><p>13.<lb/>14. Every year, the<lb/>adhesions of which the<lb/>matter of corruption<lb/>is the cement, will<lb/>be the closer.<lb/>Having tasted of the<lb/>sweets of power, few<lb/>will willingly <sic>submitt</sic><lb/>to be debarred<lb/>from them.<lb/>-----</p><p>III 1 14.<lb/>Sole reason for<lb/>undiscontinued relocability,<lb/>the word <hi rend="underline">experience</hi>:<lb/>experience gained by<lb/>Deputies the first year,<lb/>and so on.</p><p>15.<lb/>16. But vague and<lb/>delusive is the idea<lb/>presented by it. If relevant,<lb/>it must mean<lb/><hi rend="underline">applied in all branches,</hi><lb/>particularly moral,<lb/>in which <sic>it's</sic> utility <gap/><lb/>the others depend.<lb/>But, in the moral,<lb/>instead of aptitude,<lb/>inaptitude, as above, is<lb/>the result, <add>and</add> the<lb/>intellectual and active<lb/>aptitude, being subservient<lb/>to the moral<lb/>inaptitude, are worse<lb/>than useless.<lb/>-----</p><p>IV. 1. 16 <del>15</del><lb/>17. Not having power,<lb/>influence of will on<lb/>will &#x2014; nothing but the<lb/>less uniform influence<lb/>of understanding on<lb/>understanding, <hi rend="underline">Continuation</hi><lb/><hi rend="underline">Committee men</hi> can not<lb/>be corrupted or<lb/>corruptors. so easily as <gap/> <gap/>.</p><pb/><note>§.4. Experienceis <gap/> <gap/><lb/><gap/>.17. 18. 19<lb/><gap/> 2. Non-relocability<gap/>, who<lb/>not perpetual. 19 6 22.</note><lb/>Ch. VI. legislative<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale<p>17 <del><gap/></del><lb/>18. To Deputies, situation<lb/>will not give intellectual<lb/>and active aptitude<lb/>equal to what it will to<lb/><hi rend="underline">Committee men</hi>. Electors,<lb/>and Judges, of the aptitude<lb/>of <hi rend="underline">Deputies</hi>, the comparatively<lb/>uninformed and<lb/>inattentive Electors: of<lb/><hi rend="underline">Committeemen</hi>, the<lb/>maximizedly informed and<lb/>attached Deputies.</p><p>18.<lb/>19. For want of the stimulus<lb/>applied by competition,<lb/>the Deputies,  if there be<lb/>no Continuation<lb/>Committee, will have no<lb/>need to strengthen, by<lb/>exercise, their intellectual<lb/>and active aptitude.<lb/>Not so, those who look to<lb/>the Committee men.</p><p>19.<lb/>20. But "<hi rend="underline">experience</hi>" should<lb/>be applied to the situation<lb/>of Electors, as well<lb/>as of Deputies: in Deputies,<lb/>it means <hi rend="underline">exercise</hi><lb/>in the performance of<lb/>the business of the assembly:<lb/>in Electors, exercise<lb/>in the habit of taking note<lb/>of the conduct of Deputies<lb/>with a view to the relocation<lb/>so as to judge between<lb/>competitor &amp; competitor.<lb/>-----</p><p>20<lb/>21. Quest 2 Relocability. why<lb/>not perpetual.</p><p>21.<lb/>Reason. If it were, those who<lb/>alone have had practice<lb/>will be excluded from<lb/>competition with those<lb/>who have had none.<!-- The previous paragraph has been stricken. --></p><p>22.<lb/>23. What is desirable is<lb/>that as soon as the requisite<lb/>number of persons<lb/>who have had practice in<lb/>their situations, &amp; whose<lb/>conduct in it the Electors have<lb/>had the means of observing<lb/>is completed,the Elector sh<hi rend="superscript">d.</hi><lb/>have the benefit of that <gap/><lb/>information &amp; this they<lb/>can not have without<lb/>relocability.</p>
<note>B Feb<hi rend="superscript">y</hi>Supersedes after Apr. 5 by a<lb/>first Draught</note>
<note>1826. Feb<hi rend="superscript">y.</hi> 3</note>
<head>Constitutional Code.</head>
 
<p>Ch. VI. Legislative.<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale</p>
<p>1.<lb/>Quest 1. Non-relocability,<lb/>why<lb/>Ans. 1. From undiscontinued<lb/>relocability,<lb/>evil in all shapes:<lb/>good in none.</p>
<p>2.<lb/>2. to public, all good<lb/>expected from it is secured<lb/>by Continuation Committee<lb/>with addition,<lb/>and without evil.</p>
<p>3.<lb/>3. To public, the evil<lb/>has for immediate cause<lb/>relative inaptitude in<lb/>all shapes.</p>
<p>4.<lb/>4. To deputies, evil<lb/>none; because<lb/>disappointment none: those<lb/>whom the Constitution<lb/>finds located excepted:<lb/>whence the grand<lb/>obstruction.</p>
<p>5.<lb/>5. Of the evil immediate<lb/>cause, relative<lb/>inaptitude in all shapes<lb/><del>6.</del><lb/><del>6. <gap/></del> taken together:<lb/>for, by relocability<lb/>the first location is<lb/>made tantamount<lb/>to d<hi rend="superscript">o.</hi> for life:<lb/>non-relocation, <add>to</add> dislocation.<lb/>The first locatee pleads<lb/>appropriate services:<lb/>neither now nor ever can<lb/><del>now or ever can be</del><lb/>non locatee plead any: by<lb/>no negative inaptitude<lb/>can a man be ousted:<lb/>only by flagrant<lb/>positive. Thus, the first<lb/>year; by every other, the<lb/>hold is strengthened.</p>
<pb/>
<p>Ch. VI. Legislative.<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale<p><del>7</del>6.<lb/>7. Next are moral in<lb/>particular. All will<lb/>be corrupted. Ordinary<lb/>price that of the mutes:<lb/>higher &amp; higher those of<lb/>the speakers &amp; managers.</p>
<p><del>8>/del>7.<lb/>Corruptors, the Prime<lb/>Justice Minister, chief<lb/>givers of good gifts &#x2014;<lb/>2. Leading Electors.<lb/>-----<lb/>II. 6 8.<lb/>9. Matter, by expectation of<lb/>which, deputies will be<lb/>corrupted. Offices for their<lb/>connections.</p>
<p>9.<lb/>10. Matter, <add>by</add>expectation of<lb/>which Ministers will be<lb/>corrupted by, expectation<lb/>of power and emolument<lb/><sic>encreased</sic>, responsibility<lb/>diminished.</p>
<p>11.<lb/>11. Matter, by expectation<lb/>of which, leading Electors<lb/>will be corrupted by<lb/>services rendered to them<lb/>in their individual<lb/>capacity.<lb/>1. Minor good gifts thro'<lb/>Ministers.<lb/>2. Personal courtesy and<lb/>flattery towards themselves.<lb/>-----</p><p>11 <del>12.</del><lb/>11. In both cases, corruption<lb/>safe, <hi rend="underline">no statement</hi><lb/><hi rend="underline">of terms</hi> &#x2014; no <hi rend="underline">bargains</hi><lb/>being necessary: no<lb/>exposure to punishment<lb/>or shame.</p>
<pb/>
<note>§. 1. From undiscontinued<lb/>relocability d<hi rend="superscript">o</hi> corrupted: observe<lb/>evil <gap/> <gap/> in all<lb/>shapes, 2. in moral: 1 L 7<lb/>§. 2. Matter of corruption 8. 4 15<lb/>§. 3. <hi rend="underline">Experience</hi> <gap/> 146</note>
<p>Ch. VI. Legislative.<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale</p>
<p>12.<lb/>13. In the moral, attraction<lb/>of corruption is<lb/>what d<hi rend="superscript">o.</hi> of gravity is<lb/>in the physical world.</p><p>13.<lb/>14. Every year, the<lb/>adhesion, of which the<lb/>matter of corruption<lb/>is the cement, will<lb/>be the closer.<lb/>Having tasted of the<lb/>sweets of power, few<lb/>will willingly <sic>submitt</sic><lb/>to be debarred<lb/>from them.<lb/>-----</p>
 
<p>III 1 14.<lb/>Sole reason for<lb/>undiscontinued relocability,<lb/>the word <hi rend="underline">experience</hi>:<lb/>experience gained by<lb/>Deputies the first year,<lb/>and so on.</p>
<p>15.<lb/>16. But vague and<lb/>delusive is the idea<lb/>presented by it. If relevant,<lb/>it must mean<lb/><hi rend="underline">applied in all branches,</hi><lb/>particularly moral,<lb/>in which <sic>it's</sic> utility on<lb/>the others depend.<lb/>But, in the moral,<lb/>instead of aptitude,<lb/>inaptitude, as above, is<lb/>the result, <add>and</add> the<lb/>intellectual and active<lb/>aptitude, being subservient<lb/>to the moral<lb/>inaptitude, are worse<lb/>than useless.<lb/>-----</p>
 
<p>IV. 1. 16 <del>15</del><lb/>17. Not having power,<lb/>influence of will on<lb/>will &#x2014; nothing but the<lb/>less uniform influence<lb/>of understanding on<lb/>understanding, <hi rend="underline">Continuation</hi><lb/><hi rend="underline">Committee men</hi> can not<lb/>be corruptees or<lb/>corruptors. so easily as <gap/> <gap/>.</p>
<pb/>
<note>§.4. Experience is <gap/> <gap/><lb/><gap/>.17. 18. 19<lb/><gap/> 2. Non-relocability, who<lb/>not perpetual. 19 6 22.</note>
<p>Ch. VI. Legislative<lb/>§. Relocable who.<lb/>Rationale</p>
<p>17 <del><gap/></del><lb/>18. To Deputies, situation<lb/>will not give intellectual<lb/>and active aptitude<lb/>equal to what it will to<lb/><hi rend="underline">Committee men</hi>. Electors,<lb/>and Judges, of the aptitude<lb/>of <hi rend="underline">Deputies</hi>, the comparatively<lb/>uninformed and<lb/>inattentive Electors: of<lb/><hi rend="underline"><sic>Committeemen</sic></hi>, the<lb/>maximizedly informed and<lb/>attached Deputies.</p>
 
<p>18.<lb/>19. For want of the stimulus<lb/>applied by competition,<lb/>the Deputies,  if there be<lb/>no Continuation<lb/>Committee, will have no<lb/>need to strengthen, by<lb/>exercise, their intellectual<lb/>and active aptitude.<lb/>Not so, those who look to<lb/>the Committee men.</p>
<p>19.<lb/>20. But "<hi rend="underline">experience</hi>" should<lb/>be applied to the situation<lb/>of Electors, as well<lb/>as of Deputies: in Deputies,<lb/>it means <hi rend="underline">exercise</hi><lb/>in the performance of<lb/>the business of the assembly:<lb/>in Electors, exercise<lb/>in the habit of taking note<lb/>of the conduct of Deputies<lb/>with a view to the relocation<lb/>so as to judge between<lb/>competitor &amp; competitor.<lb/>-----</p>
<p>20<lb/>21. Quest 2 Relocability. why<lb/>not perpetual.</p>
<p>21.<lb/>Reason. If it were, those who<lb/>alone have had practice<lb/>will be excluded from<lb/>competition with those<lb/>who have had none.<!-- The previous paragraph has been stricken. --></p>
<p>22.<lb/>23. What is desirable is<lb/>that as soon as the requisite<lb/>number of persons<lb/>who have had practice in<lb/>their situations, &amp; whose<lb/>conduct in it the Electors have<lb/>had the means of observing<lb/>is completed,the Elector sh<hi rend="superscript">d.</hi><lb/>have the benefit of that <gap/><lb/>information &amp; this they<lb/>can not have without<lb/>relocability.</p>






<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}}

Latest revision as of 09:49, 4 February 2020

Click Here To Edit

B FebySupersedes after Apr. 5 by a
first Draught
1826. Feby. 3 Constitutional Code.

Ch. VI. Legislative.
§. Relocable who.
Rationale

1.
Quest 1. Non-relocability,
why
Ans. 1. From undiscontinued
relocability,
evil in all shapes:
good in none.

2.
2. to public, all good
expected from it is secured
by Continuation Committee
with addition,
and without evil.

3.
3. To public, the evil
has for immediate cause
relative inaptitude in
all shapes.

4.
4. To deputies, evil
none; because
disappointment none: those
whom the Constitution
finds located excepted:
whence the grand
obstruction.

5.
5. Of the evil immediate
cause, relative
inaptitude in all shapes
6.
6. taken together:
for, by relocability
the first location is
made tantamount
to do. for life:
non-relocation, to dislocation.
The first locatee pleads
appropriate services:
neither now nor ever can
now or ever can be
non locatee plead any: by
no negative inaptitude
can a man be ousted:
only by flagrant
positive. Thus, the first
year; by every other, the
hold is strengthened.


---page break---

Ch. VI. Legislative.
§. Relocable who.
Rationale

76.
7. Next are moral in
particular. All will
be corrupted. Ordinary
price that of the mutes:
higher & higher those of
the speakers & managers.

8>/del>7.
Corruptors, the Prime
Justice Minister, chief
givers of good gifts —
2. Leading Electors.
-----
II. 6 8.
9. Matter, by expectation of
which, deputies will be
corrupted. Offices for their
connections.

9.
10. Matter, byexpectation of
which Ministers will be
corrupted by, expectation
of power and emolument
encreased, responsibility
diminished.

11.
11. Matter, by expectation
of which, leading Electors
will be corrupted by
services rendered to them
in their individual
capacity.
1. Minor good gifts thro'
Ministers.
2. Personal courtesy and
flattery towards themselves.
-----

11 12.
11. In both cases, corruption
safe, no statement
of terms — no bargains
being necessary: no
exposure to punishment
or shame.


---page break---
§. 1. From undiscontinued
relocability do corrupted: observe
evil in all
shapes, 2. in moral: 1 L 7
§. 2. Matter of corruption 8. 4 15
§. 3. Experience 146

Ch. VI. Legislative.
§. Relocable who.
Rationale

12.
13. In the moral, attraction
of corruption is
what do. of gravity is
in the physical world.

13.
14. Every year, the
adhesion, of which the
matter of corruption
is the cement, will
be the closer.
Having tasted of the
sweets of power, few
will willingly submitt
to be debarred
from them.
-----

III 1 14.
Sole reason for
undiscontinued relocability,
the word experience:
experience gained by
Deputies the first year,
and so on.

15.
16. But vague and
delusive is the idea
presented by it. If relevant,
it must mean
applied in all branches,
particularly moral,
in which it's utility on
the others depend.
But, in the moral,
instead of aptitude,
inaptitude, as above, is
the result, and the
intellectual and active
aptitude, being subservient
to the moral
inaptitude, are worse
than useless.
-----

IV. 1. 16 15
17. Not having power,
influence of will on
will — nothing but the
less uniform influence
of understanding on
understanding, Continuation
Committee men can not
be corruptees or
corruptors. so easily as .


---page break---
§.4. Experience is
.17. 18. 19
2. Non-relocability, who
not perpetual. 19 6 22.

Ch. VI. Legislative
§. Relocable who.
Rationale

17
18. To Deputies, situation
will not give intellectual
and active aptitude
equal to what it will to
Committee men. Electors,
and Judges, of the aptitude
of Deputies, the comparatively
uninformed and
inattentive Electors: of
Committeemen, the
maximizedly informed and
attached Deputies.

18.
19. For want of the stimulus
applied by competition,
the Deputies, if there be
no Continuation
Committee, will have no
need to strengthen, by
exercise, their intellectual
and active aptitude.
Not so, those who look to
the Committee men.

19.
20. But "experience" should
be applied to the situation
of Electors, as well
as of Deputies: in Deputies,
it means exercise
in the performance of
the business of the assembly:
in Electors, exercise
in the habit of taking note
of the conduct of Deputies
with a view to the relocation
so as to judge between
competitor & competitor.
-----

20
21. Quest 2 Relocability. why
not perpetual.

21.
Reason. If it were, those who
alone have had practice
will be excluded from
competition with those
who have had none.

22.
23. What is desirable is
that as soon as the requisite
number of persons
who have had practice in
their situations, & whose
conduct in it the Electors have
had the means of observing
is completed,the Elector shd.
have the benefit of that
information & this they
can not have without
relocability.




Identifier: | JB/038/280/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 38.

Date_1

1826-02-03

Marginal Summary Numbering

1-22

Box

038

Main Headings

constitutional code

Folio number

280

Info in main headings field

constitutional code

Image

001

Titles

ch. vi legislative / relocable who / rationale

Category

marginal summary sheet

Number of Pages

1

Recto/Verso

recto

Page Numbering

e1

Penner

john flowerdew colls

Watermarks

Marginals

Paper Producer

Corrections

jeremy bentham

Paper Produced in Year

Notes public

[[notes_public::"superseded after art. 5 by a fresh draught" [note in bentham's hand]]]

ID Number

11917

Box Contents

UCL Home » Transcribe Bentham » Transcription Desk
  • Create account
  • Log in