JB/096/128/001: Difference between revisions

Transcribe Bentham: A Collaborative Initiative

From Transcribe Bentham: Transcription Desk

Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.

JB/096/128/001: Difference between revisions

RexL (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
BenthamBot (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE -->


<p>
  <p>
I call Pleasure, every sensation <del><add>perception</add></del> that <del>the</del> a<lb/>  
                    I call Pleasure, every sensation <del><add>perception</add></del> that <del>the</del> a<lb/>  
man had rather feel at that instant than<lb/>  
                    man had rather feel at that instant than<lb/>  
feel <hi rend='underline'>none</hi>.
                    feel <hi rend='underline'>none</hi>.
</p>
                </p>
 
               
<p>
                <p>
I call Pain every sensation that a man<lb/>  
                    I call Pain every sensation that a man<lb/>  
had rather feel none than feel.
                    had rather feel none than feel.
</p>
                </p>
 
               
<p>
                <p>
"I call Pleasure," says <del>Maupertuis</del> <add>a celebrated French</add> Philosopher,<hi rend='superscript'>||</hi><lb/>
                    "I call Pleasure," says <del>Maupertuis</del> <add>a celebrated French</add> Philosopher,<hi rend='superscript'>||</hi><lb/>
<note><hi rend='superscript'>||</hi>Maupertuis <foreign>Essai de Philosophie Moral Oeuvres</foreign>  Tome I.<hi rend='superscript'><unclear>Ch.I</unclear></hi> Lyon 1756 p. 194</note><lb/>  
                    <note><hi rend='superscript'>||</hi>Maupertuis <foreign>Essai de Philosophie Moral Oeuvres</foreign>  Tome I.<hi rend='superscript'><unclear>Ch.I</unclear></hi> Lyon 1756 p. 194</note>
"every <del><gap/></del>sensation<hi rend='superscript'>+</hi> <note><hi rend='superscript'>+</hi>The word is "<hi rend='underline'>Perception</hi>" &#x2014; it makes no difference.</note> that a man had rather <hi rend='underline'>feel</hi> than <hi rend='underline'>not</hi> feel<!-- JB first underlined "not feel," then deleted the underlining.-->.
                    <lb/>  
</p>
                    "every <del>pre</del> sensation<hi rend='superscript'>+</hi> <note><hi rend='superscript'>+</hi>The word is "<hi rend='underline'>Perception</hi>" &#x2014; it makes no difference.</note> that a man had rather <hi rend='underline'>feel</hi> than <hi rend='underline'>not</hi> feel<!-- JB first underlined "not feel," then deleted the underlining.-->.
 
                </p>
<p>
               
I call Pain, continues he, <del>that</del> every sensation<lb/>
                <p>
that a man had rather <hi rend='underline'>not</hi> feel<lb/>  
                    I call Pain, continues he, <del>that</del> every sensation<lb/>
than <hi rend='underline'>feel</hi>.
                    that a man had rather <hi rend='underline'>not</hi> feel<lb/>  
</p>
                    than <hi rend='underline'>feel</hi>.
                </p>
<p>
               
"Every sensation", <add>he</add> says <del>be</del> again, .... "during<lb/>
                <p>
which a man would neither wish to<lb/>  
                    "Every sensation", <add>he</add> says <del>be</del> again, .... "during<lb/>
sleep, nor to <hi rend='underline'>pass on to any other sensation</hi><lb/>
                    which a man would neither wish to<lb/>  
<note>I hope thus much is enough to make an end of this Philosophical <unclear>Roman</unclear> of which the Moral is Go hang yourself.  "<foreign><unclear>Abi cito &amp; suspende te</unclear></foreign>."<!-- This marginal note begins on this page, and continues on the next page. --></note>
                    sleep, nor to <hi rend='underline'>pass on to any other sensation</hi><lb/>
every such A sensation is a pleasure.  The<lb/>  
                    <note>I hope thus much is enough to make an end of this Philosophical Romance of which the Moral is Go hang yourself.  "<foreign><unclear>Abi cito &amp; suspende te</unclear></foreign>."<!-- This marginal note begins on this page, and continues on the next page. --></note>
time which such A sensation lasts is what
                    every such A sensation is a pleasure.  The<lb/>  
 
                    time which such A sensation lasts is what
 
                   
<pb/>
                   
 
                    <pb/>
 
                   
I call the <hi rend='underline'>happy moment.</hi>
                   
</p>
                    I call the <hi rend='underline'>happy moment.</hi>
                </p>
<p><add><hi rend='underline'>A moment</hi></add>  He might call it: <del>a moment</del> <add>nor after this</add> <del><unclear>we</unclear></del> need we<lb/>  
               
<del>not</del> be <sic>surprized</sic> at <del>finding</del> reading <del>in</del> the <add><del><gap/> for</del> at the</add><lb/>
                <p><add><hi rend='underline'>A moment</hi></add>  He might call it: <del>a moment</del> <add>nor after this</add> <del><unclear>we</unclear></del> need we<lb/>  
<del><gap/></del><add>head of</add> his next chapter - "That in common<lb/> life the sum of <hi rend='underline'>evil</hi> surpasses that of <hi rend='underline'>good."</hi><lb/>
                    <del>not</del> be <sic>surprized</sic> at <del>finding</del> reading <del>in</del> the <add><del><gap/> for</del> at the</add><lb/>
A melancholy conclusion this:<add> it must be confessed:</add> and happily<lb/>
                    <del><gap/></del><add>hand of</add> his next chapter - "That in common<lb/> life the sum of <hi rend='underline'>evil</hi> surpasses that of <hi rend='underline'>good."</hi><lb/>
as  <del><unclear>erroneous</unclear></del> <add>ill-founded</add> as it is melancholy.  According<lb/>
                    A melancholy conclusion this:<add> it must be confessed:</add> and happily<lb/>
to his definitions, <add>especially the last of them,</add> no man should be deemed<lb/>
                    as  <del><unclear>erroneous</unclear></del> <add>ill-founded</add> as it is melancholy.  According<lb/>
to have a fortune, but Crassus - No<lb/>
                    to his definitions, <add>especially the last of them,</add> no man should be deemed<lb/>
man to have <sic>heighth</sic>, but <sic>Goliah</sic>, or the tallest<lb/> of the Patagonians - No woman beauty,<lb/>
                    to have a fortune, but Crassus &#x2014; No<lb/>
but Venus - No pleasure in short is a<lb/>
                    man to have <sic>heighth</sic>, but <sic>Goliah</sic>, or the tallest<lb/> of the Patagonians &#x2014; No woman beauty,<lb/>
pleasure, but the highest a man knows of.<lb/>   
                    but Venus &#x2014; No pleasure in short is a<lb/>
He goes on, as one might imagine, (for<lb/>
                    pleasure, but the highest a man knows of.<lb/>   
tho' unfortunate in this and some other instances<lb/>
                    He goes on, as one might imagine, (for<lb/>
<del>the man</del> <add>Maupertuis</add> was a mathematician, and if he<lb/> <unclear>erred</unclear> it was with method and precision) -<lb/>
                    tho' unfortunate in this and some other instances<lb/>
he goes on, and says,<del><gap/></del> Every sensation <del><gap/></del>.....<lb/>
                    <del>the man</del> <add>Maupertuis</add> was a mathematician, and if he<lb/> <unclear>erred</unclear> it was with method and precision) -<lb/>
during which a man would wish to<add> sleep, or to</add> pass on to  
                    he goes on, and says,<del><gap/></del> Every sensation <del><gap/></del>.....<lb/>
 
                    during which a man would wish to<add> sleep, or to</add> pass on to  
<pb/>
                   
 
                    <pb/>
<del><gap/></del>any other, every such sensation <del>I call</del><add>is</add> a <lb/>
                   
Pain.</p>
                    <del><gap/></del>any other, every such sensation <del>I call</del> <add>is</add> a <lb/>
                    Pain.</p>
<head>NOTE</head>
            </div>
<p> I thought I had made a sort of a discovery,<lb/>
            <div>
when it had occurred to me that the quantity<lb/>
                <head>NOTE</head>
of Happiness or Unhappiness in any given<lb/>
               
subject was to be calculated upon these<lb/>
                <p>I thought I had made a sort of a discovery,<lb/>
dimensions; and had drawn up a few <add>propositions</add> <del><unclear>axioms</unclear></del><lb/>
                    when it had occurred to me that the quantity<lb/>
upon that principle.  <note>I had hit upon this method of <add>analysis for of</add> analyzing * our perceptions.  The idea of these two dimensions, when it first occurred, seemed new to me: I thought I had made a sort of discovery when I thought of <del>[...?]</del> <gap/> it up as a model to analyze all our sensations by.</note>  I was much <sic>surprized</sic><lb/> upon <add>turning</add> <del><unclear>looking</unclear></del> <add>turning</add> over the works of that ingenious<lb/>
                    of Happiness or Unhappiness in any given<lb/>
Philosopher to find the idea anticipated.<lb/>  
                    subject was to be calculated upon these<lb/>
<add>Beyond these two dimensions indeed he does not go</add> <del>He goes however no further than <gap/></del>  
                    dimensions; and had drawn up a few <add>propositions</add> <del><unclear>axioms</unclear></del><lb/>
<del><note>of these two dimensions and</note></del><lb/>
                    upon that principle.  <note>I had hit upon this method of <add>analysis for </add> analyzing * our perceptions.  The idea of these two dimensions, when it first occurred, seemed new to me: I thought I had made a sort of discovery when I thought of <del><gap/></del> <gap/> it up as a model to analyze all our sensations by.</note>  I was much <sic>surprized</sic><lb/> upon <add>turning</add> <del><unclear>looking</unclear></del> <add>turning</add> over the works of that ingenious<lb/>
The <del>book</del> <add>tract</add> <del>Essay on Moral Philosophy</del> in<lb/>
                    Philosopher to find the idea anticipated.<lb/>  
which it <sic>occurrs,</sic> for all the useful and  <del><unclear>fundamental</unclear></del><add>original</add><lb/>
                    <add>Beyond these two dimensions indeed he does not go</add> <del>He goes however no further than <gap/></del>  
hints it contains is <del>very</del> <add>but</add> little<lb/>
                    <del><note>of these two dimensions and</note></del><lb/>
known in this country: it has not <del>that I</del><add>I believe</add><lb/>
                    The <del>book</del> <add>tract</add> <del>Essay on Moral Philosophy</del> in<lb/>
<del>know of</del> been translated into our language.<lb/>  
                    which it <sic>occurrs</sic>, for all the useful and  <del><unclear>fundamental</unclear></del><add>original</add><lb/>
The <add>truth is the</add> positions <del><gap/></del> <add>in it</add> are <add>for the most part</add> as false as they are<lb/>
                    hints it contains is <del>very</del> <add>but</add> little<lb/>
uncomfortable: which may serve to account for  
                    known in this country: it has not <del>that I</del> <add>I believe</add><lb/>  
 
                    <del>know of</del> been translated into our language.<lb/>  
 
                    The <add>truth is the</add> positions <del><gap/></del> <add>in it</add> are <add>for the most part</add> as false as they are<lb/>
<pb/>
                    uncomfortable: which may serve to account for  
 
                    </p>
the little notice that has been taken of it.<lb/>
                   
<del>The</del> <del><gap/> <unclear>sources</unclear> of <gap/> <unclear>mentioned</unclear></del> <del><add>reason of these<unclear> being</unclear> <unclear>so</unclear> are</add></del><lb/>
                    <pb/>
The fundamental errors <add>seem to be</add> <del>are</del> - this <del><unclear>that</unclear></del> I have<lb/>
                   
been taking notice of: and another which I shall<lb/>
                <p>  the little notice that has been taken of it.<lb/>
have occasion to mention presently.<note> had occasion to <add>take notice of</add> mention before.</note></p>
                    <del>The</del> <del>formidable <unclear>sources</unclear> of <gap/> <unclear>mentioned</unclear></del> <del><add>reason of these<unclear> being</unclear> <unclear>so</unclear> are</add></del><lb/>
 
                    The fundamental errors <add>seem to be</add> <del>are</del> - this <del><unclear>that</unclear></del> I have<lb/>
<p> Yes, says Maupertuis, "the pleasures of <del><gap/></del><add>that a</add><lb/>
                    been taking notice of: and another which I shall<lb/>
<add>man finds in increasing his riches and his powers</add><del>and <gap/><gap/> pleasures of <unclear>possession</unclear></del><lb/>
                    have occasion to mention presently.<note> had occasion to <add>take notice of</add> mention before.</note></p>
(pleasures of possession and expectation<lb/>
               
as I <del>should</del> call them, <del>and expectation</del><lb/>
                <p>Yes, says Maupertuis, "the pleasures of <del><gap/></del><add>that a</add><lb/>
are pleasures, but they are pleasures<lb/>
                    <add>man finds in increasing his riches and his powers</add><del>and <gap/><gap/> pleasures of <unclear>possession</unclear></del><lb/>
of the body - How so? because they <del>are</del><lb/>
                    (pleasures of possession and expectation<lb/>
originate in the body - they suppose the<lb/>
                    as I <del>should</del> call them, <del>and expectation</del><lb/>
existence of the pleasures of the body <note>which a man proposes, by means of his riches or his power, to procure</note> without<lb/>
                    are pleasures, but they are pleasures<lb/>
which they would be themselves <unclear>no</unclear> pleasures.<note> ib. p.212</note><note>They are nothing else <add>than</add> <del>but</del> pleasures of the body seen as a distance.</note>  Then you make no pleasures<lb/>
                    of the body &#x2014; How so? because they <del>are</del><lb/>
of the mind? - Oh, Yes says he, but I do.<lb/>
                    originate in the body - they suppose the<lb/>
There are just two [sorts] of them; <del>and</del> I<lb/>
                    existence of the pleasures of the body <note>which a man proposes, by means of his riches or his power, to procure</note> without<lb/>
will tell you what they are.  One is, the<lb/>
                    which they would be themselves <unclear>no</unclear> pleasures.<note> ib. p.212</note><note>They are nothing else <add>than</add> <del>but</del> pleasures of the body seen as a distance.</note>  Then you make no pleasures<lb/>
<hi rend='underline'>practise of Justice.</hi>  The other is, <hi rend='underline'>the view</hi></p>
                    of the mind? - Oh, Yes says he, but I do.<lb/>
 
                    There are just two [sorts] of them; <del>and</del> I<lb/>
<head>Maupertuis</head>
                    will tell you what they are.  One is, the<lb/>
 
                    <hi rend='underline'>practise of Justice.</hi>  The other is, <hi rend='underline'>the view</hi></p>
            </div>
            <div>
                <head>Maupertuis</head>
               
               
            </div>






<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}}

Latest revision as of 10:11, 4 February 2020

Click Here To Edit

I call Pleasure, every sensation perception that the a
man had rather feel at that instant than
feel none.

I call Pain every sensation that a man
had rather feel none than feel.

"I call Pleasure," says Maupertuis a celebrated French Philosopher,||
||Maupertuis Essai de Philosophie Moral Oeuvres Tome I.Ch.I Lyon 1756 p. 194
"every pre sensation+ +The word is "Perception" — it makes no difference. that a man had rather feel than not feel.

I call Pain, continues he, that every sensation
that a man had rather not feel
than feel.

"Every sensation", he says be again, .... "during
which a man would neither wish to
sleep, nor to pass on to any other sensation
I hope thus much is enough to make an end of this Philosophical Romance of which the Moral is Go hang yourself. "Abi cito & suspende te." every such A sensation is a pleasure. The
time which such A sensation lasts is what
---page break---
I call the happy moment.

A moment He might call it: a moment nor after this we need we
not be surprized at finding reading in the for at the
hand of his next chapter - "That in common
life the sum of evil surpasses that of good."
A melancholy conclusion this: it must be confessed: and happily
as erroneous ill-founded as it is melancholy. According
to his definitions, especially the last of them, no man should be deemed
to have a fortune, but Crassus — No
man to have heighth, but Goliah, or the tallest
of the Patagonians — No woman beauty,
but Venus — No pleasure in short is a
pleasure, but the highest a man knows of.
He goes on, as one might imagine, (for
tho' unfortunate in this and some other instances
the man Maupertuis was a mathematician, and if he
erred it was with method and precision) -
he goes on, and says, Every sensation .....
during which a man would wish to sleep, or to pass on to
---page break---
any other, every such sensation I call is a
Pain.

               NOTE
               

I thought I had made a sort of a discovery,
when it had occurred to me that the quantity
of Happiness or Unhappiness in any given
subject was to be calculated upon these
dimensions; and had drawn up a few propositions axioms
upon that principle. I had hit upon this method of analysis for analyzing * our perceptions. The idea of these two dimensions, when it first occurred, seemed new to me: I thought I had made a sort of discovery when I thought of it up as a model to analyze all our sensations by. I was much surprized
upon turning looking turning over the works of that ingenious
Philosopher to find the idea anticipated.
Beyond these two dimensions indeed he does not go He goes however no further than of these two dimensions and
The book tract Essay on Moral Philosophy in
which it occurrs, for all the useful and fundamentaloriginal
hints it contains is very but little
known in this country: it has not that I I believe
know of been translated into our language.
The truth is the positions in it are for the most part as false as they are
uncomfortable: which may serve to account for

                   
---page break---

the little notice that has been taken of it.
The formidable sources of mentioned reason of these being so are
The fundamental errors seem to be are - this that I have
been taking notice of: and another which I shall
have occasion to mention presently. had occasion to take notice of mention before.

Yes, says Maupertuis, "the pleasures of that a
man finds in increasing his riches and his powersand pleasures of possession
(pleasures of possession and expectation
as I should call them, and expectation
are pleasures, but they are pleasures
of the body — How so? because they are
originate in the body - they suppose the
existence of the pleasures of the body which a man proposes, by means of his riches or his power, to procure without
which they would be themselves no pleasures. ib. p.212They are nothing else than but pleasures of the body seen as a distance. Then you make no pleasures
of the mind? - Oh, Yes says he, but I do.
There are just two [sorts] of them; and I
will tell you what they are. One is, the
practise of Justice. The other is, the view

               Maupertuis
               
               




Identifier: | JB/096/128/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 96.

Date_1

Marginal Summary Numbering

Box

096

Main Headings

legislation

Folio number

128

Info in main headings field

maupertuis i

Image

001

Titles

note

Category

text sheet

Number of Pages

1

Recto/Verso

recto

Page Numbering

Penner

jeremy bentham

Watermarks

[[watermarks::gr [crown motif] [britannia with shield motif]]]

Marginals

Paper Producer

Corrections

Paper Produced in Year

Notes public

ID Number

31132

Box Contents

UCL Home » Transcribe Bentham » Transcription Desk
  • Create account
  • Log in