★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''[{{fullurl:JB/107/028/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | '''[{{fullurl:JB/107/028/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
Fallacies<lb/> | <p>Fallacies<lb/> | ||
Anti- | Anti-innovational</p> | ||
<p>1 Danger of <lb/> | <p>1 Danger of <lb/> | ||
<del>of</del> Innovation | <del>of</del> Innovation</p> | ||
<p>2 Argumentum<lb/> | <p>2 <foreign>Argumentum</foreign><lb/> | ||
ab ignorantia <add>a</add> <unclear>adicantis</unclear>< | <foreign>ab ignorantia <add>a</add></foreign> <foreign><unclear>adicantis</unclear></foreign></p> | ||
<p>3. Too good to be practicable | <p>3. Too good to be practicable</p> | ||
<p>4 Good in theory<lb/> | <p>4 Good in theory<lb/> | ||
therefore not good<lb/> | therefore not good<lb/> | ||
in practice | in practice</p> | ||
<p>5. Too soon, too<lb/> | <p>5. Too soon, too<lb/> | ||
early - <foreign>ad | early - <foreign>ad tempus</foreign></p> | ||
<p>6. Too late - <foreign>ad</foreign><lb/> | <p>6. Too late - <foreign>ad</foreign><lb/> | ||
<foreign | <foreign>tempus</foreign></p> | ||
<p>7. It has not the<lb/> | <p>7. It has not the<lb/> | ||
support of men of<lb/> | support of men of<lb/> | ||
conviction in that<lb/> | |||
time - <del><gap/></del> i:e:<lb/> | |||
of men | of men interested<lb/> | ||
to oppose every<lb/> | to oppose every<lb/> | ||
thing that is good<lb/> | thing that is good<lb/> | ||
in proportion as it<lb/> | in proportion as it<lb/> | ||
is good. | is good.</p> | ||
<p>8. no proof | <p>8. no proof of the mischiefs<lb/> | ||
having already <lb/> | having already <lb/> | ||
happened. | happened.</p> | ||
<p>All this is<lb/> | <p>All this is<lb/> | ||
<foreign>Non | <foreign>Non amo te</foreign><lb/> | ||
<foreign><unclear> | <foreign><unclear>Sabidi</foreign></p> | ||
<p><foreign>Est-ce que nous</foreign><lb/> | <p><foreign>Est-ce que nous</foreign><lb/> | ||
<foreign>ne sommes pas</foreign><lb/> | <foreign>ne sommes pas</foreign><lb/> | ||
<foreign>bien</foreign | <foreign>bien</foreign></p> | ||
<p>Can we be better<lb/> | <p>Can we be better<lb/> | ||
off than we are? | off than we are?</p> | ||
<p>8. There is no<lb/> | <p>8. There is no<lb/> | ||
saying what it may<lb/> | saying what it may<lb/> | ||
| Line 47: | Line 47: | ||
this reason, it would<lb/> | this reason, it would<lb/> | ||
be in any man's<lb/> | be in any man's<lb/> | ||
power to | power to damn a<lb/> | ||
good <del><gap/></del> <unclear>law</unclear> by | good <del><gap/></del> <unclear>law</unclear> by treacherously</p><pb/> | ||
< | <p>Vulgar Errors</p><lb/> | ||
<p>Prosperity of the<lb/> | <p>Prosperity of the<lb/> | ||
Nation depending <lb/> | Nation depending <lb/> | ||
on the exertions if<lb/> | on the exertions if<lb/> | ||
a | a Minister -<lb/> | ||
- On the | - On the personal<lb/> | ||
interference of<lb/> | interference of<lb/> | ||
the King</p> | |||
<p>Such | <p>Such authorities<lb/> | ||
from History< | from History</p> | ||
9. <foreign> <hi rend='underline'>a motivis</hi></foreign>< | <p>9. Argumentum <foreign><hi rend='underline'>a motivis</hi></foreign></p> | ||
Argument from the <lb/> | <p>Argument from the <lb/> | ||
supposed bad motive <lb/> | supposed bad motive <lb/> | ||
attributed to the proposer<lb/> | attributed to the proposer<lb/> | ||
| Line 71: | Line 71: | ||
bad? - because <lb/> | bad? - because <lb/> | ||
the measure is bad.</p> | the measure is bad.</p> | ||
<p>10 <foreign>Argumentum ab</foreign> <lb/> | <p>10 <foreign>Argumentum ab</foreign><lb/> | ||
<foreign>< | <foreign><gap/></foreign> - <unclear>complaining</unclear> of <hi rend='underline'><unclear>word- catching</unclear></hi><lb/> | ||
Answer. By what can<lb/> | Answer. By what can<lb/> | ||
a man | a man answering be <lb/> | ||
judged of but by his <lb/> | judged of but by his <lb/> | ||
words? - if you don't <lb/> | words? - if you don't <lb/> | ||
quote his words - then <lb/> | quote his words - then <lb/> | ||
the cry is | the cry is unfairness<lb/> | ||
< | <unclear>even</unclear> misrepresentation or<lb/> | ||
those were not his words<lb/> | |||
—< | —</p><pb/> | ||
<p>We are to punish<lb/> | <p>We are to punish<lb/> | ||
ourselves and the country<lb/> | |||
by rejecting a<lb/> | by rejecting a<lb/> | ||
good law, because<add>for the | good law, because<add>for the value of</add> because<lb/> | ||
somebody <add>who</add> has | somebody <add>who</add> has professed<lb/> | ||
it in | it in sympathy with bad ones.</p> | ||
<p>—<lb/><pb/> | <p>—<lb/><pb/> | ||
-<del> | -<del>who are</del> only proposing<lb/> | ||
it as part of a bad <lb/> | it as part of a bad<lb/> | ||
system. | system.</p><pb/> | ||
<p>no instance of< | <p>11. <add>no instance of</add>The mischief<lb/> | ||
against which the<lb/> | against which the<lb/> | ||
law is intended<lb/> | law is intended<lb/> | ||
as a remedy has<lb/> | as a remedy has<lb/> | ||
now happened. | now happened.</p> | ||
<p>Stable Door | <p>Stable Door never<lb/> | ||
to be shut | to be shut till a<lb/> | ||
steed has been already<lb/> | steed has been already<lb/> | ||
stolen</p> | stolen</p> | ||
<p>12. No complaint<lb/> | <p>12. No complaint<lb/> | ||
of the mischief<lb/> | of the mischief<lb/> | ||
has ever been | has ever been made<lb/> | ||
Answer Complaint<lb/> | Answer Complaint<lb/> | ||
is not made but<lb/> | is not made but<lb/> | ||
under prospect of<lb/> | under prospect of<lb/> | ||
redress. | redress.</p> | ||
<p>The badness of the<lb/> | <p>The badness of the<lb/> | ||
measure is | measure is provided<lb/> | ||
<del>by</del> the corruption<lb/> | <del>by</del> the corruption<lb/> | ||
<del>the | <del>the measure is</del><lb/> | ||
of the | of the men.<lb/> | ||
<del>bad, <unclear>however</unclear></del><lb/> | <del>bad, <unclear>however</unclear></del><lb/> | ||
<del> | <del>the men who support</del><lb/> | ||
<del>it | <del>it are corrupt.</del> The <unclear>more</unclear><lb/> | ||
corruption | corruption of the<lb/> | ||
men is provided<lb/> | |||
by the badness<lb/> | by the badness<lb/> | ||
of the measure. | of the measure.</p> | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}} | ||
Fallacies
Anti-innovational
1 Danger of
of Innovation
2 Argumentum
ab ignorantia a adicantis
3. Too good to be practicable
4 Good in theory
therefore not good
in practice
5. Too soon, too
early - ad tempus
6. Too late - ad
tempus
7. It has not the
support of men of
conviction in that
time - i:e:
of men interested
to oppose every
thing that is good
in proportion as it
is good.
8. no proof of the mischiefs
having already
happened.
All this is
Non amo te
<unclear>Sabidi
Est-ce que nous
ne sommes pas
bien
Can we be better
off than we are?
8. There is no
saying what it may
lead to - It is part
of a bad plan - adopt
this part, it may
lead to the adoption
of the whole. Ex.
Toleration might lead
to the subversion of the
Church - Answer Admit if
this reason, it would
be in any man's
power to damn a
good law by treacherously
---page break---
Vulgar Errors
Prosperity of the
Nation depending
on the exertions if
a Minister -
- On the personal
interference of
the King
Such authorities
from History
9. Argumentum a motivis
Argument from the
supposed bad motive
attributed to the proposer
- This is reasoning
in a circle.
The measure is bad
because the motives
are bad - Why do
you conclude the motives
bad? - because
the measure is bad.
10 Argumentum ab
- complaining of word- catching
Answer. By what can
a man answering be
judged of but by his
words? - if you don't
quote his words - then
the cry is unfairness
even misrepresentation or
those were not his words
—
---page break---
We are to punish
ourselves and the country
by rejecting a
good law, becausefor the value of because
somebody who has professed
it in sympathy with bad ones.
—
---page break---
-who are only proposing
it as part of a bad
system.
---page break---
11. no instance ofThe mischief
against which the
law is intended
as a remedy has
now happened.
Stable Door never
to be shut till a
steed has been already
stolen
12. No complaint
of the mischief
has ever been made
Answer Complaint
is not made but
under prospect of
redress.
The badness of the
measure is provided
by the corruption
the measure is
of the men.
bad, however
the men who support
it are corrupt. The more
corruption of the
men is provided
by the badness
of the measure.
|
Identifier: | JB/107/028/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 107. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
107 |
fallacies |
||
|
028 |
fallacies |
||
|
001 |
fallacies / anti-innovational / vulgar errors |
||
|
plan |
2 |
||
|
recto |
|||
|
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::l munn [britannia emblem]]] |
||
|
benjamin constant |
|||
|
35019 |
|||
