★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
<p>"No one will adventure upon the commission of any enormous < | <p>"No one will adventure upon the commission of any enormous<lb/> | ||
crime"- This, according to one made of interpretation, <lb/> | |||
is <del>a proposition</del>, <add>a proposition which;</add><del>an independent proposition</del> <lb/> | |||
<add>a proposition</add> by which the existence of a <unclear>custom</unclear> state of things - and <lb/> | <add>a proposition</add> by which the existence of a <unclear>custom</unclear> state of things - and <lb/> | ||
unquestionably of it did<add>did it but</add> but exist a very happy one-<add>state of things-</add><lb/> | unquestionably of it did<add>did it but</add> but exist a very happy one-<add>state of things-</add><lb/> | ||
is announced <add>d<gap/>d<add><unclear>uposted</unclear></add> in the chancellor of <del>a cause</del> an <hi rend="underline">effect</hi>.<lb/> | is announced <add>d<gap/>d <add><unclear>uposted</unclear></add></add> in the chancellor of <del>a cause</del> an <hi rend="underline">effect</hi>.<lb/> | ||
<add>The</add> <hi rend="underline">Cause</hi> <add>of it, as indicated immediately after</add> <del>indicated</del> by the word <hi rend="underline">from</hi>, a knowledge that the<lb/> | <add>The</add> <hi rend="underline">Cause</hi> <add>of it, as indicated immediately after</add> <del>indicated</del> by the word <hi rend="underline">from</hi>, a knowledge that the<lb/> | ||
laws <del>have</del> have <hi rend="underline">not</hi> provided for its punishment.'<lb/></p> | laws <del>have</del> have <hi rend="underline">not</hi> provided for its punishment.'<lb/></p> | ||
This interpretation, though in <sic>gramatical</sic> point<lb/> | <p>This interpretation, though in <sic>gramatical</sic> point<lb/> | ||
of view the most obvious interpretation, being in a rational<lb/> | of view the most obvious interpretation, being in a rational<lb/> | ||
point of view untenable, we are reduced to look<lb/> | point of view untenable, we are reduced to look<lb/> | ||
out for another; and as others can be expressed but by<lb/> | out for another; and as others can be expressed but by<lb/> | ||
a paraphrase, substituting <del>what appears</del> <add><del>present</del></add> to an <add>indeterminate and</add | a paraphrase, substituting <del>what appears</del> <add><del>present</del></add> to an <add>indeterminate and</add> unintelligible<lb/> | ||
clause that<add>which</add> presents itself as the nearest intelligible<lb/> | clause that<add>which</add> presents itself as the nearest intelligible<lb/> | ||
one. | one. There does not <del>exist</del> <add><del>(let us say)</del></add> On the part of<lb/> | ||
any one who has in contemplation the commission of<lb/> | any one who has in contemplation the commission of<lb/> | ||
any enormous crime, <add>there <del>does</del><add> | any enormous crime, <add>there <del>does</del> <add>exists</add><add>not(let us say) <add>fashion</add> <add>exist</add> any such knowledge <add>of</add> <del>respecting</del><lb/> | ||
<add>the non-existence of any absence of all</add>On provision made for its punishment, as will <del>be sufficient</del><add>cause</add><lb/> | <add>the non-existence of any absence of all</add>On provision made for its punishment, as will <del>be sufficient</del> <add>cause</add><lb/> | ||
him to adventure upon the commission of<lb/> | him to adventure upon the commission of<lb/> | ||
it. In this <add>sense</add> insipid and trifling as the proposition<lb/> | it. In this <add>sense</add> insipid and trifling as the proposition<lb/> | ||
is, it can not be charged with being | is, it can not be charged with being untrue: but as<lb/> | ||
the characters of an argument in favour of the | the characters of an argument in favour of the system of<lb/> | ||
punishment, of the <unclear>excellency</unclear> of which it is | punishment, of the <unclear>excellency</unclear> of which it is | ||
employed to<lb/> | employed to<lb/> | ||
help persuade us, <del>it amounts to</del><add>what does it amount to? - really</add> nothing - forasmuch<lb/> | help persuade us, <del>it amounts to</del><add>what does it amount to? - really</add> nothing - forasmuch<lb/> | ||
as it would apply, and with the same form, in <unclear>justification</unclear><lb/> | as it would apply, and with the same form, in <unclear>justification</unclear><lb/> | ||
of any other system of punishment<del>,</del> <add>which <del>stood</del> <note>happened to stand annext</note></add>to the offence<lb/><lb/> | of any other system of punishment<del>,</del> <add>which <del>stood</del> <note>happened to stand <unclear>annext</unclear></note></add> to the offence<lb/><lb/> | ||
here in question:- any punishment - no matter what - so it<lb/> | |||
even but punishment. <del>were annext</del>, [+]<note>[+] under his system in regard to punishment, so far as it extends, there will always be some a motive for | even but punishment. <del>were annext</del>, [+]<note>[+] under his system in regard to punishment, so far as it extends, there will always be some a motive for abstaining from crimes. True: and so <del>there</del> will there under any other system. Yet this is among the arguments by which the superiority of this to every other system is <del><gap/></del> according to his notion of the matter proved.</note></p> | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}} | ||
"No one will adventure upon the commission of any enormous
crime"- This, according to one made of interpretation,
is a proposition, a proposition which;an independent proposition
a proposition by which the existence of a custom state of things - and
unquestionably of it diddid it but but exist a very happy one-state of things-
is announced dd <add>uposted</add> in the chancellor of a cause an effect.
The Cause of it, as indicated immediately after indicated by the word from, a knowledge that the
laws have have not provided for its punishment.'
This interpretation, though in gramatical point
of view the most obvious interpretation, being in a rational
point of view untenable, we are reduced to look
out for another; and as others can be expressed but by
a paraphrase, substituting what appears present to an indeterminate and unintelligible
clause thatwhich presents itself as the nearest intelligible
one. There does not exist (let us say) On the part of
any one who has in contemplation the commission of
any enormous crime, there does <add>existsnot(let us say) <add>fashion exist any such knowledge of respecting
the non-existence of any absence of allOn provision made for its punishment, as will be sufficient cause
him to adventure upon the commission of
it. In this sense insipid and trifling as the proposition
is, it can not be charged with being untrue: but as
the characters of an argument in favour of the system of
punishment, of the excellency of which it is
employed to
help persuade us, it amounts towhat does it amount to? - really nothing - forasmuch
as it would apply, and with the same form, in justification
of any other system of punishment, which stood happened to stand annext to the offence
here in question:- any punishment - no matter what - so it
even but punishment. were annext, [+][+] under his system in regard to punishment, so far as it extends, there will always be some a motive for abstaining from crimes. True: and so there will there under any other system. Yet this is among the arguments by which the superiority of this to every other system is according to his notion of the matter proved.
|
Identifier: | JB/107/226/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 107. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
1809-01-30 |
5 |
||
|
107 |
law versus arbitrary power (a hatchet for dr paley's net) |
||
|
226 |
peines |
||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
e25 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
|||
|
35217 |
|||
