★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
<head>Peines</head> | <head>Peines</head> | ||
<p>S3 Add. But there is a supposition that more has been a<lb/> | <p>S3 Add. But there is a supposition that more has been a<lb/> | ||
can be | can be verified. In that under unwritten law there is no <gap/>ative:<lb/> | ||
name but <unclear>never</unclear> <hi rend="underline">written</hi>: <hi rend="underline">there</hi> is the | name but <unclear>never</unclear> <hi rend="underline">written</hi>: <hi rend="underline">there</hi> is the only, <hi rend="underline"><gap/></hi>:</p> | ||
<p>Suppose indeed a choice of decisions following one<lb/> | <p>Suppose indeed a choice of decisions following one<lb/> | ||
another and carried to such a length as to have driven<lb/> | another and carried to such a length as to have driven<lb/> | ||
out the rule which itself, <del><gap/></del> according<add>in proportion</add> to the | out the rule which itself, <del><gap/></del> according <add>in proportion</add> to the extract<lb/> | ||
assumed< | assumed <add><unclear>unbraced</unclear></add> by it, taken through the authority of the only<lb/> | ||
genuine sort of law<add>genuine law - the written & statute law</add> and to the same extent drawn<lb/> | genuine sort of law <add>genuine law - the written & statute law</add> and to the same extent drawn<lb/> | ||
out justice - here indeed<add>on this supposition</add> the mischief of the | out justice - here indeed <add>on this supposition</add> the mischief of the infraction <note>and so rule after rule till at last in this narrow <add>corrupt</add> principle the principle of nullification were <add>had been</add> consigned <hi rend="underline">in toto</hi> to that abhorence <add>infamy</add> with which should ever proper <unclear>bear</unclear> <unclear>undisputed</unclear> sway it will be entered</note><lb/> | ||
could have waned<add>vanished</add>, and the benefit<add>produced by it</add> would remain<lb/> | could have waned <add>vanished</add>, and the benefit <add>produced by it</add> would remain<lb/> | ||
pure. Now might it to be overlooked, that, by the <lb/> | pure. Now might it to be overlooked, that, by the <lb/> | ||
infraction of a rule of<add>judicial</add> procedure, by which the <del><gap/>th</del><lb/> | infraction of a rule of <add>judicial</add> procedure, by which the <del><gap/>th</del><lb/> | ||
disposition of the substantive or main branch of the law<lb/> | disposition of the substantive or main branch of the law<lb/> | ||
is overthrown and a contempt put upon the | is overthrown and a contempt put upon the authority of the only legitimate legislator, whatsoever mischief<lb/> | ||
may in manner above mentioned <add>be</add> produced, is | may in manner above mentioned <add>be</add> produced, is | ||
neither equal in degree <unclear>was</unclear> altogether the same in<lb/> | neither equal in degree <unclear>was</unclear> altogether the same in<lb/> | ||
| Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
main body of the law, especially <unclear>if of</unclear> that point of it <lb/> | main body of the law, especially <unclear>if of</unclear> that point of it <lb/> | ||
which is the wish of the legitimate legislator. It is<lb/> | which is the wish of the legitimate legislator. It is<lb/> | ||
take a | take a decision made by the lawful owner upon the <add>a</add> de<gap/>or<lb/> | ||
one usurption made by the lawful sovereign or even<lb/> | one usurption made by the lawful sovereign or even<lb/> | ||
by another usurption upon a first usurper. The mischief,<lb/> | by another usurption upon a first usurper. The mischief,<lb/> | ||
| Line 46: | Line 46: | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}} | ||
Feby 1809 Peines
S3 Add. But there is a supposition that more has been a
can be verified. In that under unwritten law there is no ative:
name but never written: there is the only, :
Suppose indeed a choice of decisions following one
another and carried to such a length as to have driven
out the rule which itself, according in proportion to the extract
assumed unbraced by it, taken through the authority of the only
genuine sort of law genuine law - the written & statute law and to the same extent drawn
out justice - here indeed on this supposition the mischief of the infraction and so rule after rule till at last in this narrow corrupt principle the principle of nullification were had been consigned in toto to that abhorence infamy with which should ever proper bear undisputed sway it will be entered
could have waned vanished, and the benefit produced by it would remain
pure. Now might it to be overlooked, that, by the
infraction of a rule of judicial procedure, by which the th
disposition of the substantive or main branch of the law
is overthrown and a contempt put upon the authority of the only legitimate legislator, whatsoever mischief
may in manner above mentioned be produced, is
neither equal in degree was altogether the same in
kind with the mischief produced by an infraction
of the equally manifest of an instant playing as above to the
main body of the law, especially if of that point of it
which is the wish of the legitimate legislator. It is
take a decision made by the lawful owner upon the a deor
one usurption made by the lawful sovereign or even
by another usurption upon a first usurper. The mischief,
if not reduced 0 would in this case be at any rate
reduced to a comparatively small quantity:- why?
because it follows not that a Judge by whom disobedience
is paid to the usurped power of the predecessors to no other
effect than the paying obedience to their acknowledged sovereign,
would on another occasion manifest the same contempt
towards the only genuine sort which he has been manifesting towards
spurious laws.
---page break---
|
Identifier: | JB/107/256/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 107. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
1809-02-06 |
16 |
||
|
107 |
law versus arbitrary power (a hatchet for dr paley's net) |
||
|
256 |
peines |
||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
e55 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
|||
|
35247 |
|||
