★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
'''[{{fullurl:JB/159/013/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | '''[{{fullurl:JB/159/013/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
<head>Punishment | <p>5</p> | ||
distinctions by examining the use that is made of | <p><head>Punishment 𝓧 Restraint – Warburton </head></p> | ||
them. | <p>distinctions by examining the use that is made of<lb/> | ||
<p>An act of restraint then is < | them.</p> | ||
pain is inflicted < | <p>An act of restraint then is <add>according to his Lordship</add> any act whereby<lb/> | ||
"to reflect the evil it is | pain is inflicted but <add>"no</add> more than what is just necessary<lb/> | ||
<p>An act of punishment is < | "to reflect the evil it is employ'd to combat.</p> | ||
pain is inflicted "more than what is just | <p>An act of punishment is a<add>ccording to his Lordship</add> any act whereby<lb/> | ||
pain is inflicted "more than what is just necessary<lb/> | |||
<p>Here however I find myself under another | "to repel the evil" it is employ'd to combat</p> | ||
<p>Here however I find myself under another embarassment:<lb/> | |||
used in < | for the word <hi rend="underline">evil</hi> is by <del>his Lordship</del> <add>the Bishop</add> | ||
< | used in <del>a sense</del> <add>two senses</add> which to his Lordship seems <add><del>both</del></add><lb/> | ||
least seems inaccurate, and both together dis | <add>both of them</add> accurate and <add>as well as</add> familiar: but of which <add>to <unclear>me</unclear></add> one at<lb/> | ||
< | least seems inaccurate, and both together dis<add>parate<lb/> | ||
<p>Of evils he makes two sorts | to & in</add>consistent | ||
crimes. <del> | disparate to and inconsistent with each other.</p> | ||
evil that proceeds not from the will". | <p>Of evils he makes two <add><del>opposite</del> </add>sorts<hi rend="superscript">⊞</hi> <note><hi rend="superscript">⊞</hi> which two sorts are mentioned as distinct & opposite.</note>: mischief and<lb/> | ||
is "an evil that < | crimes. <del>Any</del> A mischief is, with him, <del><gap/></del> a new <add>"an</add><lb/> | ||
<p>If this < | evil that proceeds not from the will". A crime<lb/> | ||
in case of our meeting with any evil that does | is "an evil that <add>does</add> proceed from the will". </p> | ||
<del>not</del>proceed from the will that it is not a | <p>If this <del>is</del> be <del>too</del> accurate, it will be true to say<lb/> | ||
mischief. If then < | in case of our meeting with any evil that does<lb/> | ||
is in such < | <del>not</del>proceed from the will that it is not a<lb/> | ||
pain his Lordship <del><gap/></del>in consequence of <del> | mischief. If then <del>I let you</del> <add>a man were to give his Lordship <del>give you</del> a blow</add> voluntarily that<lb/> | ||
<add>is in such manner that the</add> pain <del>you</del> <add>his Lordship</add> felt in consequence of man's giving <del>you</del> him the blow | |||
not a mischief. Such a position, I imagine, is | pain his Lordship <del><gap/></del>in consequence of <del>many beating your</del> <add>the man's giving <del>you</del> him the blow</add><lb/> | ||
more than | proceed<del>ing</del><add>ed</add> from <del>you –any</del> <add>the man's</add> will, such pain is<lb/> | ||
not a mischief. Such a position, I imagine, is<lb/> | |||
more than <del>you</del> <add>his Lordship</add> would be willing to allow.</p> | |||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{ | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}} | ||
5
Punishment 𝓧 Restraint – Warburton
distinctions by examining the use that is made of
them.
An act of restraint then is according to his Lordship any act whereby
pain is inflicted but "no more than what is just necessary
"to reflect the evil it is employ'd to combat.
An act of punishment is according to his Lordship any act whereby
pain is inflicted "more than what is just necessary
"to repel the evil" it is employ'd to combat
Here however I find myself under another embarassment:
for the word evil is by his Lordship the Bishop
used in a sense two senses which to his Lordship seems both
both of them accurate and as well as familiar: but of which to me one at
least seems inaccurate, and both together disparate
to & inconsistent
disparate to and inconsistent with each other.
Of evils he makes two opposite sorts⊞ ⊞ which two sorts are mentioned as distinct & opposite.: mischief and
crimes. Any A mischief is, with him, a new "an
evil that proceeds not from the will". A crime
is "an evil that does proceed from the will".
If this is be too accurate, it will be true to say
in case of our meeting with any evil that does
notproceed from the will that it is not a
mischief. If then I let you a man were to give his Lordship give you a blow voluntarily that
is in such manner that the pain you his Lordship felt in consequence of man's giving you him the blow
pain his Lordship in consequence of many beating your the man's giving you him the blow
proceedinged from you –any the man's will, such pain is
not a mischief. Such a position, I imagine, is
more than you his Lordship would be willing to allow.
|
Identifier: | JB/159/013/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 159. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
159 |
punishment |
||
|
013 |
punishment & restraint warburton |
||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
4 |
||
|
recto |
f5 / f6 / f7 / f8 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::l v g propatria [britannia motif]]] |
||
|
caroline vernon |
|||
|
53836 |
|||
