JB/008/042/001: Difference between revisions

Transcribe Bentham: A Collaborative Initiative

From Transcribe Bentham: Transcription Desk

★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts

JB/008/042/001: Difference between revisions

← Older edit
No edit summary
Keithompson (talk | contribs)
10,223 edits
m Protected "JB/008/042/001": ready for review ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))
 
(14 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
'''[{{fullurl:JB/008/042/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]'''
'''[{{fullurl:JB/008/042/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]'''
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE -->
<p><head>&sect;.2.  Creoles unwilling<lb/>
<p>1820 Aug. 20</p>
<note>&sect;.3  Constitut<hi rend="superscript">n</hi> bars Sample of Creolia.</note></head></p>
<p>28 Dec 1820 Extract and post fro, 4 | 6 Constitution<lb/>
<p>Objection – All this submitted<lb/>
paralogues the dominion</p>
to before the change,<lb/>
<p>&sect;.2.  Creoles unwilling</p>
why not afterwards?<lb/>
<p>&sect;.1 Good to Spain. and to Creolia.</p>
Submitted to under a bad<lb/>
<p>II. Much more, supposing<lb/>
government, people not<lb/>
sharing in it, why not under<lb/>
a good, people so largely<lb/>
sharing?</p>
 
<p>8.<lb/>
Answer.  Plausible this,<lb/>
and displayed to best advantage:<lb/>
but insufficient.<lb/>
But it will be seen, that, to exclude<lb/>
<del>Spain</del> from Spain <gap/> <unclear>profit</unclear><lb/>
may be expected from Creolia<lb/>
&amp; <unclear>maybe</unclear> disenchanted.</p>
 
9.<lb/>
Under despotism, manacles, <lb/>
gags, bandages universal;<lb/>cc
now none.
 
 
 
 
 
 
<p><head>1820 Aug. 20<lb/></head></p>
<p><head>&sect;.2.  Creoles unwilling<lb/>
<note>&sect;.2 Good to Spaniard in Creolia.</note></head></p>
<p>II. Much more, supposing<lb/>
repugnance in Creolia<lb/>
repugnance in Creolia<lb/>
– the whole, or any<lb/>
- the whole, or any<lb/>
part. With repugnance,<lb/>
part. With repugnance<lb/>
real, supposed, or pretended,<lb/>
real, supposed, or pretended,<lb/>
would encrease preparation,<lb/>
would encrease preparation, <lb/>
and expence<lb/>
and expence<lb/>
of preparation, for surmounting<lb/>
of preparaion, for surmounting <lb/>
it: it would<lb/>
it: it would<lb/>
encrease with the number<lb/>
encrease with the number<lb/>
of discontended provinces;<lb/>
of discontented provinces:<lb/>
and the number<lb/>
and the number<lb/>
of discontented in each,<lb/>
of discontented in each<lb/>
so in case of revolt, or disobediences. <del>obedience</del> <add>If not on their own<lb/>
so in case of revolt, or dis<add>obediences</add>
account, Creoles have <unclear>claim</unclear> to regard<lb/>
<del>obedience</del> <lb/>
If not on their own<lb/>
account, Creoles have shown to regard<lb/>
from Spanish subject many on their<lb/>
from Spanish subject many on their<lb/>
account: the stronger the <unclear>suffering</unclear> the stronger the <gap/>.</add></p>
account: the <!-- <!-- Red ink --> -->stronger the suffering<lb/>
<p>With every arrangement<lb/>
<!-- Black ink -->With every arrangement<lb/>
by which benefit were supposed<lb/>
<!-- Red ink -->the stronger the resistance<lb/>
<!-- Black ink -->by which benefit were supposed<lb/>
afforded to Spain<lb/>
afforded to Spain<lb/>
at the charge of Creolia,<lb/>ccrepugnance, discontent,<lb/>
at the charge of Creolia<lb/>
repugnance, discontent<lb/>
disobedience, revolt would<lb/>
disobedience, revolt would<lb/>
encrease.</p>c<p>3<lb/>
encrease.</p>
3<lb/>
<p>3</p>
<add>Here then it comes to be Reason that</add>
<p>Here then it comes to be<lb/>
The repugnance is<lb/>
shown that</p>
certain: its root is in the<lb/>
<p>3</p>
<p>The repugnance is<lb/>
certain: its root is in the <lb/>
nature of the relation,<lb/>
nature of the relation,<lb/>
coupled with that of the<lb/>
coupled with that of the<lb/>
constitutional change.</p>
constitutional change.</p>
<p>4.<lb/>
<p>4</p>
Shewn <hi rend="underline">below</hi> governments<lb/>
<p>Shewn <hi rend="underline">below</hi>, governments<lb/>
separated, interests<lb/>
separated, interests<lb/>
united.<lb/>
united.</p>
But governments united,<lb/>
<p>But governments united,<lb/>
interests opposite.</p>
interests opposite.</p>
<p>5.<lb/>
<p>5</p>
<add>Shown <hi rend="underline">above</hi></add><lb/>
<p>Shewn <hi rend="underline">above</hi></p>
To Spain no advantage,<lb/>
<p>To Spain no advantage,<lb/>
without <add>greatly</add> corresponding<lb/>
without <add>greater</add> corresponding<lb/>
disadvantage to Creolia:<lb/>
disadvantage to Creolia:<lb/>
Shewn, already, the<lb/>
Shewn, already, the<lb/>
Line 82: Line 60:
the sufficient cause of<lb/>
the sufficient cause of<lb/>
this.</p>
this.</p>
<p><head><note>&sect;.2  Evil to Creolia, <hi rend="underline"><foreign>Sans</foreign></hi> good to Sp<hi rend="superscript">n.</hi></note></head></p>
<p>&sect;<!-- red ink -->2. Evil to Creolia, <hi rend="underline">sans</hi> good to Sp<add>n</add>.</p>
<p>To the arrangement by<lb/>
<p><!-- Black ink -->To the arrangement by<lb/>
which, coupled with greater<lb/>
which coupled with greater<lb/>
disadvantage to Creolia<lb/>
disadvantage to Creolia<lb/>
would be advantage to<lb/>
would be advantage to<lb/>
Spain, add others covering<lb/> b
Spain, add others covering<lb/>
the whole field, and not<lb/>
the whole field, and not<lb/>
productive of any such advantage:<lb/>
productive of any such advantage:<lb/>
Sample present,<lb/>
sample presently,<lb/>
<hi rend="underline">Appeals.</hi></p>
<hi rend="underline">appeals</hi>.</p><pb/>
<pb/>
 
 
<p>&sect;.3. Creoles unwilling</p>
&sect;.3  Constitut<hi rend="superscript">n</hi> bars Sample of <lb/>
Creolia.</p>
<p>Objection – All this submitted<lb/>
to before the change,<lb/>
why not afterwards?<lb/>
Submitted to under a bad<lb/>
government, people not<lb/>
sharing in it, why not under<lb/>
a good, people so largely<lb/>
sharing?</p>
 
<p>8.<lb/>
<p>Answer.  Plausible this,<lb/>
and displayed to best advantage:<lb/>
but insufficient.</p>
 
<p>But it will be seen, that, to exclude<lb/>
<del>Spain</del> from Spain <gap/> <unclear>profit</unclear><lb/>
may be expected from Creolia<lb/>
simple <del><gap/></del> disenchanted.<lb/>
will be sufficient under the Constitutional<lb/>
Code given to both be<lb/>
sufficient: simple dis<gap/>nation<lb/>
without need of revolt or<lb/>
illegal resistance.</p>
<p>9.<lb/>
Under despotism, manacles, <lb/>
gags, bandages universal;<lb/>cc
now none.<lb/>
1. By Art 371, press free.<lb/>
2. By Art 373. Memorializing<lb/>
free.<lb/>
<gap/> Postpone this about<lb/>
3. Under the despotism,<add>free com<gap/>ate</add><lb/>
Creolia shut against all<lb/>
foreigners. Now, (sittings of<lb/>
Aug. 1820) open to all<</p>
<p>10</p>
<p>4. Under despotism, end<lb/>
of government, happiness <lb/>
of <hi rend="underline">one</hi>: per art.133, of all:<lb/>
i.e. where there is competition,<lb/>
greatest happiness<lb/>
of greatest number.</p>
<p>11</p>
<p>Either these laws will be<lb/>
dead, or every Creolian,<lb/>
who feels aggrieved by any<lb/>
act of Cortes, will proclaim<lb/>
it in all ways. But every<lb/>
Creolian will be aggrieved<lb/>
by multitudes of such acts<lb/>
some with (as above,) some<lb/>
without, advantage to Spain<lb/>
as below.</p>
<p><!-- Red ink -->&sect; Resistance probably exp<gap/> necessitated</p>
<p>Causes so ample and universal,<lb/>
with such means of<lb/>
expression and propagation,<lb/>
discontent, and, through disaffection<lb/>
and disobedience,<lb/>
revolt,ccan they long fail?</p>
<p><!-- Red ink -->&sect; Continue on with <hi rend="underline">their Rights<lb/></hi>&amp; 86,87,88, 89, 90, 91.92.<lb/>
93.</p><pb/>
 


<p>&sect;.3. Creoles unwilling</p>
<p><!-- In red ink -->&sect;.4. Resistance probable, expence necessitated.</p>
<p>By any demonstration of<lb/>
submission at the outset,<lb/>
could rulers stand excused<lb/>
from making, almost immediately,<lb/>
expensive preparations<lb/>
against a danger<lb/>
threatening indefinite<lb/>
encrease?</p>
&#x2014;<lb/>
<p>Lett.4. Under Code, profit none,</p>
<p><!-- In red ink -->9. Constitution excludes exaction of the<lb/>
tributes</p>
<p>Not conceivable how, under<lb/>
Art 24,25,324,326,328,335,<lb/>
336, maravedi should<lb/>
come to Spain.  <!-- Sentence in red ink -->This comes<lb/>
41.42 43.</p>
<p>1. By 324,326, in each province,<lb/>
Governor, appointed<lb/>
by King, acts best as one of<lb/>
a deputation with 8 Coordinates,<lb/>
per 328, chosen by<lb/>
all inhabitants who, not<lb/>
being slaves, nor, for specified<lb/>
causes, excluded, can<lb/>
read and write. <!-- In re ink -->44 idiom</p>
<p>15.</p>
<p>2. Per 335, of the ten functions<lb/>
of this deputation, the<lb/>
first is - examining and<lb/>
approving the division<lb/>
made of the taxes required<lb/>
from the province. No approbation,<lb/>
no tax vevied.<lb/>
For extracting money for<lb/>
Spain, what tax will be approved?<lb/>
<!-- in red ink -->44 idiom.</p>
<p>16.</p>
<p>Remedy, how nugatory!<lb/>
POwer of this deputation abused:<lb/>
per 336, King may<lb/>
suspend the Members. Cortes<lb/>
thereupon Resolutions.<lb/>
Good. if but few days<lb/>
journey between King<lb/>
Deputation.</p>
<p>17 <!-- In pencil -->(HH 2)</p>
But at the capitals of New<lb/>
Granada, <sic>Chili</sic>, Peru, the <lb/>
Manillos how will it be? In<lb/>
three months, Governor's <del><gap/></del><lb/>
complaint reaches King, in<lb/>
6 months, Cortes Resolutions<lb/>
declared; after hearing the<lb/>
defence: in 9 months, they<lb/>
reach Deputation;<add>[+]</add> Thereupon,<lb/>
per 336, members of the<lb/>
reserve take the places of<lb/>
the deposed deputies, and continue<lb/>
the same conduct: <lb/><pb/>


<p>8 - March 1826</p>
<p><gap/> whether to <gap/> the<lb/>
supportive<lb/>
5: Constitution <gap/> exaction<lb/>
of the tributes</p>
<p>18</p>
<p>Specimen of the probability<lb/>
of such approbation.<lb/>
Tobacco. Of Creolian taxes<lb/>
1786, total 426,360,000<lb/>
Tobacco Tax - 100,000,000<lb/>
In Cortes, July or August<lb/>
1820, great indignation at<lb/>
it, raised in and for Spain:<lb/>
how much greater in Creolia,<lb/>
if raised in Creolia<lb/>
for Spain, for salaries<lb/>
of rulers governing Creolia<lb/>
in Spain?</p>
<p>19 <!-- In pencil -->(III.2)</p>
<p>Such the indignation at<lb/>
that tax, greater at any<lb/>
other.  If the mode alone<lb/>
were the cause, good:<lb/>
but, if the subject matter,<lb/>
scarce could any so unobjectionable<lb/>
be found.<lb/>
Tobacco, though consumed<lb/>
by the least opulent, is<lb/>
still not a necessary, but<lb/>
a luxury: in this a tax<lb/>
on it has the advantage<lb/>
of all taxes upon necessaries.<lb/>
<!-- In red ink -->Go to 46<lb/>
20</p>


<p><!-- Paragraph in red ink --><gap/> conclude with saying. No probability<lb/>
of their being willing in<lb/>
any terms: if in any, on taxes<lb/>
if no profit to Spain, all their<lb/>
shares less.</p>


<p>Spaniards you are<lb/>
young in legislation: in<lb/>
Creation what a labyrinth<lb/>
have you not made for<lb/>
yourselves! Your will well<lb/>
be lost in it.</p>
<p><!-- In red ink -->Creoles unwilling <!-- In pencil -->(1)</p>
<p>&sect;:1. Good to Spain, evil to Creolia<lb/>
1.2.3.4.5</p>
<p><!-- In red ink -->Creoles unwilling</p>
<p>&sect;.2 Evil to Creolia, sans good<lb/>
to Spain.6.</p>
<p><!-- In pencil -->(3)</p>
<p>&sect;.3. Constitution bars sacrifice<lb/>
of Creolia<add>&amp; Creole submission</add>.7.8.9..10.11.12.<lb/>
13.- and Creole submission<lb/>
12.13</p>
<p><!-- In pencil -->(<del>4</del>5)</p>
<p>&sect;.4. Resistance being probable<lb/>
cop<gap/> is necessitated.13.14</p>
<p><!-- In pencil -->(2)</p>
<p>&sect;.5. Constitution renders exaction<lb/>
of tribute impracticable<lb/>
1<del>4</del>.15.16.17.18.19</p>
<p>[+] <add>Make</add> Correct these figures, <add>correct</add> the<lb/>
result is still more unfavourable</p>
<p><!-- In red ink -->&sect;.6 <unclear>Insert</unclear> from <unclear>Domiant</unclear> impossible<lb/>
&sect;&sect;.6.7.8.9</p><p><!-- Red ink -->&sect; Continue on with <hi rend="underline">their Rights</hi></p>
&#x2014;<lb/>
<p><del>after them, other members<lb/>
chosen in the same<lb/>
way.</del></p><pb/>


<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{In_Progress}}
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Ready_For_Review}}

Latest revision as of 08:29, 28 September 2025

Click Here To Edit

1820 Aug. 20

28 Dec 1820 Extract and post fro, 4 | 6 Constitution
paralogues the dominion

§.2. Creoles unwilling

§.1 Good to Spain. and to Creolia.

II. Much more, supposing
repugnance in Creolia
- the whole, or any
part. With repugnance
real, supposed, or pretended,
would encrease preparation,
and expence
of preparaion, for surmounting
it: it would
encrease with the number
of discontented provinces:
and the number
of discontented in each
so in case of revolt, or disobediences obedience
If not on their own
account, Creoles have shown to regard
from Spanish subject many on their
account: the -->stronger the suffering
With every arrangement
the stronger the resistance
by which benefit were supposed
afforded to Spain
at the charge of Creolia
repugnance, discontent
disobedience, revolt would
encrease.

3

Here then it comes to be
shown that

3

The repugnance is
certain: its root is in the
nature of the relation,
coupled with that of the
constitutional change.

4

Shewn below, governments
separated, interests
united.

But governments united,
interests opposite.

5

Shewn above

To Spain no advantage,
without greater corresponding
disadvantage to Creolia:
Shewn, already, the
disadvantage constantly
greater than the advantage:
expence of carriage
the sufficient cause of
this.

§2. Evil to Creolia, sans good to Spn.

To the arrangement by
which coupled with greater
disadvantage to Creolia
would be advantage to
Spain, add others covering
the whole field, and not
productive of any such advantage:
sample presently,
appeals.


---page break---


§.3. Creoles unwilling

§.3 Constitutn bars Sample of

Creolia.

Objection – All this submitted
to before the change,
why not afterwards?
Submitted to under a bad
government, people not
sharing in it, why not under
a good, people so largely
sharing?

8.

Answer. Plausible this,
and displayed to best advantage:
but insufficient.

But it will be seen, that, to exclude
Spain from Spain profit
may be expected from Creolia
simple disenchanted.
will be sufficient under the Constitutional
Code given to both be
sufficient: simple disnation
without need of revolt or
illegal resistance.

9.
Under despotism, manacles,
gags, bandages universal;
cc now none.
1. By Art 371, press free.
2. By Art 373. Memorializing
free.
Postpone this about
3. Under the despotism,free comate
Creolia shut against all
foreigners. Now, (sittings of
Aug. 1820) open to all<

10

4. Under despotism, end
of government, happiness
of one: per art.133, of all:
i.e. where there is competition,
greatest happiness
of greatest number.

11

Either these laws will be
dead, or every Creolian,
who feels aggrieved by any
act of Cortes, will proclaim
it in all ways. But every
Creolian will be aggrieved
by multitudes of such acts
some with (as above,) some
without, advantage to Spain
as below.

§ Resistance probably exp necessitated

Causes so ample and universal,
with such means of
expression and propagation,
discontent, and, through disaffection
and disobedience,
revolt,ccan they long fail?

§ Continue on with their Rights
& 86,87,88, 89, 90, 91.92.
93.


---page break---


§.3. Creoles unwilling

§.4. Resistance probable, expence necessitated.

By any demonstration of
submission at the outset,
could rulers stand excused
from making, almost immediately,
expensive preparations
against a danger
threatening indefinite
encrease?

—

Lett.4. Under Code, profit none,

9. Constitution excludes exaction of the
tributes

Not conceivable how, under
Art 24,25,324,326,328,335,
336, maravedi should
come to Spain. This comes
41.42 43.

1. By 324,326, in each province,
Governor, appointed
by King, acts best as one of
a deputation with 8 Coordinates,
per 328, chosen by
all inhabitants who, not
being slaves, nor, for specified
causes, excluded, can
read and write. 44 idiom

15.

2. Per 335, of the ten functions
of this deputation, the
first is - examining and
approving the division
made of the taxes required
from the province. No approbation,
no tax vevied.
For extracting money for
Spain, what tax will be approved?
44 idiom.

16.

Remedy, how nugatory!
POwer of this deputation abused:
per 336, King may
suspend the Members. Cortes
thereupon Resolutions.
Good. if but few days
journey between King
Deputation.

17 (HH 2)

But at the capitals of New
Granada, Chili, Peru, the
Manillos how will it be? In
three months, Governor's
complaint reaches King, in
6 months, Cortes Resolutions
declared; after hearing the
defence: in 9 months, they
reach Deputation;[+] Thereupon,
per 336, members of the
reserve take the places of
the deposed deputies, and continue
the same conduct:

---page break---

8 - March 1826

whether to the
supportive
5: Constitution exaction
of the tributes

18

Specimen of the probability
of such approbation.
Tobacco. Of Creolian taxes
1786, total 426,360,000
Tobacco Tax - 100,000,000
In Cortes, July or August
1820, great indignation at
it, raised in and for Spain:
how much greater in Creolia,
if raised in Creolia
for Spain, for salaries
of rulers governing Creolia
in Spain?

19 (III.2)

Such the indignation at
that tax, greater at any
other. If the mode alone
were the cause, good:
but, if the subject matter,
scarce could any so unobjectionable
be found.
Tobacco, though consumed
by the least opulent, is
still not a necessary, but
a luxury: in this a tax
on it has the advantage
of all taxes upon necessaries.
Go to 46
20

conclude with saying. No probability
of their being willing in
any terms: if in any, on taxes
if no profit to Spain, all their
shares less.

Spaniards you are
young in legislation: in
Creation what a labyrinth
have you not made for
yourselves! Your will well
be lost in it.

Creoles unwilling (1)

§:1. Good to Spain, evil to Creolia
1.2.3.4.5

Creoles unwilling

§.2 Evil to Creolia, sans good
to Spain.6.

(3)

§.3. Constitution bars sacrifice
of Creolia& Creole submission.7.8.9..10.11.12.
13.- and Creole submission
12.13

(45)

§.4. Resistance being probable
cop is necessitated.13.14

(2)

§.5. Constitution renders exaction
of tribute impracticable
14.15.16.17.18.19

[+] Make Correct these figures, correct the
result is still more unfavourable

§.6 Insert from Domiant impossible
§§.6.7.8.9

§ Continue on with their Rights

—

after them, other members
chosen in the same
way.


---page break---



Identifier: | JB/008/042/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 8.

Date_1

1820-08-20

Marginal Summary Numbering

1-20

Box

008

Main Headings

rid yourselves of ultramaria

Folio number

042

Info in main headings field

rid yourselves of ultramaria

Image

001

Titles

creoles unwilling

Category

marginal summary sheet

Number of Pages

1

Recto/Verso

recto

Page Numbering

d2 / e2

Penner

john flowerdew colls

Watermarks

[[watermarks::[prince of wales feathers] i&m 1818]]

Marginals

Paper Producer

arthur wellesley, duke of wellington

Corrections

jeremy bentham

Paper Produced in Year

1818

Notes public

ID Number

3146

Box Contents

Retrieved from "https://transcribe-bentham.ucl.ac.uk/index.php?title=JB/008/042/001&oldid=371783"
UCL Home » Transcribe Bentham » Transcription Desk
  • Create account
  • Log in