★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
'''[{{fullurl:JB/104/074/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | '''[{{fullurl:JB/104/074/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
<p><!-- pencil -->1 Aug. 1809</p> | |||
<p>1 Aug. 1809 | <head>Fallacies</head> | ||
<head>Fallacies | <note>Ch. 1. Generalia</note></p> | ||
<note>Ch. 1. Generalia</note> | <p><del>1. Irrelevance. 2 proof of improbity imbecillity and in <add>belief of</add> the <gap/> or <gap/><lb/> | ||
<p><del>1. Irrelevance | |||
<gap/><gap/><gap/><gap/>. Exception whose <gap/><lb/> | <gap/><gap/><gap/><gap/>. Exception whose <gap/><lb/> | ||
<gap/> in general are exploded, the influence of one <gap/><gap/><gap/><gap/ | <gap/> in general are exploded, the influence of one <gap/><gap/><gap/><gap/> <gap/><gap/><gap/><lb/> | ||
vituperation <add><gap/></add>, against under<lb/> | vituperation <add><gap/></add>, against under<lb/> | ||
<gap/> indication of <gap/><gap/><lb/> | <gap/> indication of <gap/><gap/><lb/> | ||
<gap/><gap/><gap/> influence<lb/> | <gap/><gap/><gap/> influence<lb/> | ||
of authority</ | of authority</del></p> | ||
<p><del>Ch. <gap/> § 2 6. General Character of this applicable in common<lb/> | |||
to these fallacies</del> ☞ <add>+</add> Examine as to each. <foreign>Quere</foreign> as to <hi rend="underline">Either side</hi>?</p> | |||
<p> | <p>§.6. Character applying in common to these fallacies<hi rend="superscript">+</hi>: viz. <add>Irrelevancy</add><lb/> | ||
to these fallacies | <del>1. Irrelevancy. 2. Proof of malefides or contempt of persons <add>persons addressed</add><lb/> | ||
bad cause. 3. Proof of consciousness of is badness or contempt of persons</del><lb/> | |||
<del>1. Irrelevancy. 2. Proof of | |||
bad cause. 3. Proof of | |||
addressed</p> | addressed</p> | ||
| Line 30: | Line 24: | ||
to the class of fallacies here in question, viz. <hi rend="underline">irrelevancy</hi>:<lb/> | to the class of fallacies here in question, viz. <hi rend="underline">irrelevancy</hi>:<lb/> | ||
irrelevancy with reference to the subject in hand</p> | irrelevancy with reference to the subject in hand</p> | ||
<p>Whatsoever be the proposition on the carpet, the weaker<lb/> | <p>Whatsoever be the proposition on the carpet, the weaker<lb/> | ||
| Line 44: | Line 32: | ||
the whole mass of the arguments <add>that can be</add> brought up against<lb/> | the whole mass of the arguments <add>that can be</add> brought up against<lb/> | ||
must come under this general description of irrelevant<lb/> | must come under this general description of irrelevant<lb/> | ||
ones, and upon this must rest the whole | ones, and upon this must rest the whole burthen of the<lb/> | ||
defence and the whole <add>of the</add> chance in favour of a successful one <add>success.</add></p> | defence and the whole <add>of the</add> chance in favour of a successful one <add>success.</add></p> | ||
<p>Whatsoever proposition it be that a man defends <add>part a man takes whether in the way of attack or attacks or of to defence</add>, if<lb/> | |||
<p>Whatsoever proposition it be that a man defends <add>part a man takes whether in the way of attack | |||
he would defend it with any chance of success it is necessary<lb/> | he would defend it with any chance of success it is necessary<lb/> | ||
he should appear persuaded of the propriety of defending <add>attacking</add><lb/> | he should appear persuaded of the propriety of defending <add>attacking</add><lb/> | ||
it. But if called upon for <add>a</add> reason, as in a deliberating<lb/> | it. But if called upon for <add>a</add> reason, as in a deliberating<lb/> | ||
and debating assembly he <add>of course</add> naturally will be, something under<lb/> | and debating assembly he <add>of course</add> naturally will be, something under<lb/> | ||
the guise of a reason he must come out with <add>have in store</add>, otherwise<lb/> | the guise of a reason he must come out with <add>have in store</add>, otherwise<lb/> | ||
the opposite persuasion will of course be ascribed to<lb/> | the opposite persuasion will of course be ascribed to<lb/> | ||
him.</p> | him.</p> | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{Completed}} | ||
1 Aug. 1809
Fallacies
Ch. 1. Generalia
1. Irrelevance. 2 proof of improbity imbecillity and in belief of the or
. Exception whose
in general are exploded, the influence of one
vituperation , against under
indication of
influence
of authority
Ch. § 2 6. General Character of this applicable in common
to these fallacies ☞ + Examine as to each. Quere as to Either side?
§.6. Character applying in common to these fallacies+: viz. Irrelevancy
1. Irrelevancy. 2. Proof of malefides or contempt of persons persons addressed
bad cause. 3. Proof of consciousness of is badness or contempt of persons
addressed
One character has been already mentioned as applicable
in common to fallacies in general, at any rate
to the class of fallacies here in question, viz. irrelevancy:
irrelevancy with reference to the subject in hand
Whatsoever be the proposition on the carpet, the weaker
among the arguments that in a particular manner plead against it
those that really in a particular manner belong to it the subject the greater
the demand for additional ones: and if so it be that
no such specific arguments applicable to it can be found
the whole mass of the arguments that can be brought up against
must come under this general description of irrelevant
ones, and upon this must rest the whole burthen of the
defence and the whole of the chance in favour of a successful one success.
Whatsoever proposition it be that a man defends part a man takes whether in the way of attack or attacks or of to defence, if
he would defend it with any chance of success it is necessary
he should appear persuaded of the propriety of defending attacking
it. But if called upon for a reason, as in a deliberating
and debating assembly he of course naturally will be, something under
the guise of a reason he must come out with have in store, otherwise
the opposite persuasion will of course be ascribed to
him.
|
Identifier: | JB/104/074/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 104. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
1809-08-01 |
1-3 |
||
|
104 |
fallacies |
||
|
074 |
fallacies bii ins |
||
|
001 |
character applying in common to these fallacies |
||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
d5 / e1 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
|||
|
34045 |
|||
