★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
Ch Quasi Jury<lb/> | Ch Quasi Jury<lb/> | ||
<gap/> <gap/><lb/> | <gap/> <gap/><lb/> | ||
91 | 91 or 1<lb/> | ||
cor. Incona<gap/><lb/> | <gap/>cor. Incona<gap/><lb/> | ||
Trusting these men | Trusting these men with<lb/> | ||
superlegislative power<lb/> | |||
viz. constitution, | viz. constitution, of its<lb/> | ||
refuse to trust them with<lb/> | refuse to trust them with<lb/> | ||
the <add>absolute</add> power of liberating<lb/> | the <add>absolute</add> power of liberating<lb/> | ||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
<p>§ No inconsistency in thus harnessing the power of a Jury</p> | <p>§ No inconsistency in thus harnessing the power of a Jury</p> | ||
<p>But says somebody you in whose eyes | <p>But says somebody you in whose eyes these same<lb/> | ||
individuals are not unapt to bear a paramount part in<lb/> | individuals are not unapt to bear a paramount part in<lb/> | ||
the business of legislation<add>of legislation can even | the business of legislation<add>of legislation can even an unbounded scale</add>, can you with any <unclear>consistency</unclear>, regard<lb/> | ||
those as unapt with regard to a function so <del><gap/></del> < | those as unapt with regard to a function so <del><gap/></del> <unclear>bounded</unclear><lb/> | ||
in its extent so subordinate in its importance in that of <lb/> | in its extent so subordinate in its importance in that of <lb/> | ||
pronouncing a | pronouncing a <gap/> or <gap/> in a case whether <add>in the defendants side of the cause</add> willing <gap/><lb/> | ||
is at | is at stake than the fate of this or that individual?</p> | ||
<note>92 or 2<lb/> | <note>92 or 2<lb/> | ||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
1. Only of necessity or<lb/> | 1. Only of necessity or<lb/> | ||
constitutive power given<lb/> | constitutive power given<lb/> | ||
to | to them: to no authority<lb/> | ||
<del><gap/></del> more intellectually<lb/> | <del><gap/></del> more intellectually<lb/> | ||
apt could <add>such</add> power be given<lb/> | apt could <add>such</add> power be given<lb/> | ||
| Line 39: | Line 39: | ||
<p>Answer</p> | <p>Answer</p> | ||
<p>I answer<add>Answer</add> 1. in regard to the <del><gap/></del> power I give<lb/> | <p>I answer<add>Answer</add> 1. in regard to the <del><gap/></del> power I give<lb/> | ||
to them - | to them - it is under the pressure of necessity that I give it to<lb/> | ||
them because in no other | them because in no other kind could it be riposed, without in<add>the</add><lb/> | ||
absolute certainty of its being abused.</p> | absolute certainty of its being abused.</p> | ||
| Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
<gap/> to be guided by<lb/> | <gap/> to be guided by<lb/> | ||
general reputation i:e:<lb/> | general reputation i:e:<lb/> | ||
certificates by Pub. Opinion<lb/> | |||
Tribunal: as <gap/><lb/> | Tribunal: as <gap/><lb/> | ||
superior aptitude of <gap/><lb/> | superior aptitude of <gap/><lb/> | ||
| Line 54: | Line 54: | ||
<p>2.. In the case of the power given to them as to the <gap/><lb/> | <p>2.. In the case of the power given to them as to the <gap/><lb/> | ||
of legislators, for <del><gap/></del> in no | of legislators, for <del><gap/></del> in no instance whatever is any time of the legislation<lb/> | ||
given to them, I have them <del><gap/></del> as according to all | given to them, I have them <del><gap/></del> as according to all <unclear>experience</unclear><lb/> | ||
I may without danger have them, to be assisted, and in as far as<lb/> | I may without danger have them, to be assisted, and in as far as<lb/> | ||
this phase guided by general reputation: no opinion in<lb/> | this phase guided by general reputation: no opinion in<lb/> | ||
| Line 65: | Line 65: | ||
have they: no assistance that so much as pro<gap/> to be impartial,<lb/> | have they: no assistance that so much as pro<gap/> to be impartial,<lb/> | ||
other than that of the Judge: of that very functionary,<lb/> | other than that of the Judge: of that very functionary,<lb/> | ||
to whose power the <del><gap/></del> and sole use of theirs as to apply<lb/> | to whose power the <del><gap/></del> use and sole use of theirs as to apply<lb/> | ||
a check: and under <add>to</add> whose <add>direction</add> guidance in so far as without<lb/> | a check: and under <add>to</add> whose <add>direction</add> guidance in so far as without<lb/> | ||
forming a relation to the | forming a relation to the matter are opinion of their own, they<lb/> | ||
committ themselves, their function is of <add>in efficient and useless</add> no use</p> | |||
<note>94 or 4<lb/> | <note>94 or 4<lb/> | ||
In the Judicial case<lb/> | In the Judicial case<lb/> | ||
| Line 76: | Line 76: | ||
<note>95 or 5<lb/> | <note>95 or 5<lb/> | ||
SOle assistance, Jury | |||
i.e. the very functionary<lb/> | |||
the checking of<lb/> | the checking of<lb/> | ||
whose power is the<lb/> | whose power is the<lb/> | ||
| Line 85: | Line 86: | ||
without <gap/></note><lb/> | without <gap/></note><lb/> | ||
{{ | {{Completed}} | ||
1828. August 25
Constitutional Code.
III. Rationale
Ch Quasi Jury
91 or 1
cor. Incona
Trusting these men with
superlegislative power
viz. constitution, of its
refuse to trust them with
the absolute power of liberating
an accuser evidence
§ No inconsistency in thus harnessing the power of a Jury
But says somebody you in whose eyes these same
individuals are not unapt to bear a paramount part in
the business of legislationof legislation can even an unbounded scale, can you with any consistency, regard
those as unapt with regard to a function so bounded
in its extent so subordinate in its importance in that of
pronouncing a or in a case whether in the defendants side of the cause willing
is at stake than the fate of this or that individual?
92 or 2
Answer
1. Only of necessity or
constitutive power given
to them: to no authority
more intellectually
apt could such power be given
without a certainty of
beig reviewed
Answer
I answerAnswer 1. in regard to the power I give
to them - it is under the pressure of necessity that I give it to
them because in no other kind could it be riposed, without inthe
absolute certainty of its being abused.
93 or 3
2. As to locative
legislators,
to be guided by
general reputation i:e:
certificates by Pub. Opinion
Tribunal: as
superior aptitude of
is certified by experience
2.. In the case of the power given to them as to the
of legislators, for in no instance whatever is any time of the legislation
given to them, I have them as according to all experience
I may without danger have them, to be assisted, and in as far as
this phase guided by general reputation: no opinion in
judgment of their are they in theirthat cause called upon to
pronounce. But of judicature by no one of can here be pronounced in other case no judgement can any one of the proname
any judgment which is not his own: no less direct as delted and coupled is
the cognizance taken of the matter this case their situation than in the his situation case
is that of the Judge. In the forming of it no impartial assistance
have they: no assistance that so much as pro to be impartial,
other than that of the Judge: of that very functionary,
to whose power the use and sole use of theirs as to apply
a check: and under to whose direction guidance in so far as without
forming a relation to the matter are opinion of their own, they
committ themselves, their function is of in efficient and useless no use
94 or 4
In the Judicial case
no such assistance has
the less intellectually
apt functionary.
95 or 5
SOle assistance, Jury
i.e. the very functionary
the checking of
whose power is the
sole use of all promissary
power given
to the less intellectually
functionary - So far
without
