★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
<p>"Discretion<add>in a Judge</add> is the law of tyrants: in the best it is <note>p.53</note><lb/> | <p>"Discretion<add>in a Judge</add> is the law of tyrants: in the best it is <note>p.53</note><lb/> | ||
<del> | <del>imprecise <gap/> the worst</del> it is always unknown; it is<lb/> | ||
different in different men; it casual, and depends<lb/> | different in different men; it casual, and depends<lb/> | ||
"upon constitution, temper and passion. In the best it<lb/> | "upon constitution, temper and passion. In the best it<lb/> | ||
"is | "is oftentimes, caprice, in the worst it is every vain<lb/> | ||
"folly and passion to which human nature is liable"</p> | "folly and passion to which human nature is liable"</p> | ||
<p>Such are the words <del>of the opinion attributed</del><add>published as the words of</add> to<lb/> | <p>Such are the words <del>of the opinion attributed</del><add>published as the words of</add> to<lb/> | ||
the late Lord Camden, < | the late Lord Camden, <add><del>as delivered by him when</del> Lord</add> <del>and said to have</del> been<lb/> | ||
<del><unclear>altered there</unclear></del> as contained in an opinion delivered<lb/> | <del><unclear>altered there</unclear></del> as contained in an opinion delivered<lb/> | ||
by him <gap/> 1765, in | by him <gap/> 1765, in on his then character of Lord<lb/> | ||
Chief Justice of the Common | Chief Justice of the Common <unclear>Place</unclear>, in the occasion of<lb/> | ||
to quicken respecting the <del>validity of an object</del><add> | to quicken respecting the <del>validity of an object</del><add>propriety of putting an</add> excluding<lb/> | ||
the evidence of a witness on the ground of <unclear>interest</unclear></p> | the evidence of a witness on the ground of <unclear>interest</unclear></p> | ||
<p> | |||
To those who <add>Or many of these</add> <del>are defu<gap/></del> when preserved from<lb/> | <p>To those who <add>Or many of these</add> <del>are defu<gap/></del> when preserved from<lb/> | ||
the <unclear>deceptitious</unclear> influence of this or that fallacy are preserved<lb/> | the <unclear>deceptitious</unclear> influence of this or that fallacy are preserved<lb/> | ||
from it, not by rational and relevant considerations,<lb/> | from it, not by rational and relevant considerations,<lb/> | ||
but by the influence of some fallacy acting<lb/> | but by the influence of some fallacy acting<lb/> | ||
on the other side, this would naturally enough be<lb/> | on the other side, this would naturally enough be<lb/> | ||
received in the character of a <add>most impressive and</add>triumphant | received in the character of a <add>most impressive and</add>triumphant argument,<lb/> | ||
<del>and | <del>and might</del><add>capable of</add> making a convict of many<lb/> | ||
a man and especially many a lawyer on whom<lb/> | a man and especially many a lawyer on whom<lb/> | ||
a | a <unclear>plain</unclear> representation<add>any such considerations as the above </add> of the mischief <unclear>rooted</unclear> in<add><gap/>lling from</add><lb/> | ||
<del>the shape of</del><add>general</add> | <del>the shape of</del><add>general</add> insecurity would have more disposed<lb/> | ||
to give the utmost<add>as far as depended upon him</add> < | to give the utmost<add>as far as depended upon him</add> <unclear>expression</unclear> to arbitrary power in<lb/> | ||
such hands there to apply any <gap/> to it.</p><pb/> | such hands there to apply any <gap/> to it.</p><pb/> | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | ||
10 July 1810 18
Fallacies
(2) 18
"Discretionin a Judge is the law of tyrants: in the best it is p.53
imprecise the worst it is always unknown; it is
different in different men; it casual, and depends
"upon constitution, temper and passion. In the best it
"is oftentimes, caprice, in the worst it is every vain
"folly and passion to which human nature is liable"
Such are the words of the opinion attributedpublished as the words of to
the late Lord Camden, as delivered by him when Lord and said to have been
altered there as contained in an opinion delivered
by him 1765, in on his then character of Lord
Chief Justice of the Common Place, in the occasion of
to quicken respecting the validity of an objectpropriety of putting an excluding
the evidence of a witness on the ground of interest
To those who Or many of these are defu when preserved from
the deceptitious influence of this or that fallacy are preserved
from it, not by rational and relevant considerations,
but by the influence of some fallacy acting
on the other side, this would naturally enough be
received in the character of a most impressive andtriumphant argument,
and mightcapable of making a convict of many
a man and especially many a lawyer on whom
a plain representationany such considerations as the above of the mischief rooted inlling from
the shape ofgeneral insecurity would have more disposed
to give the utmostas far as depended upon him expression to arbitrary power in
such hands there to apply any to it.
---page break---
|
Identifier: | JB/107/273/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 107. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
1810-07-30 |
|||
|
107 |
fallacies; law versus arbitrary power (a hatchet for dr paley's net) |
||
|
273 |
fallacies |
||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
c2 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
|||
|
35264 |
|||
