★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
6 Aug 1811 4 | <p>6 Aug 1811 4</p> | ||
Fallacies | <head>Fallacies</head> | ||
Generalia | <note>Generalia<lb/> | ||
Ch. Parts | Ch. Parts <unclear>bearable</unclear></note> | ||
4 | <p>4</p> | ||
In the case of the fabricator, a correspondent intention — | <p>In the case of the fabricator, a correspondent <hi rend="underline">intention</hi> —<lb/> | ||
an intention to which the same attribute evil may | an intention to which the same attribute <hi rend="underline">evil</hi> may<lb/> | ||
with propriety be | with propriety be applied, is implied when that same<lb/> | ||
attribute is applied | attribute is applied to <add>the subject of</add> <hi rend="underline">consciousness</hi>.</p> | ||
On the part of the fabricator in the case of the bad shilling suppose the absence | <p>On the part of the fabricator <add>in the case of the bad shilling</add> suppose the absence<lb/> | ||
of all intention to make in the way of utterance undue profit by the article | of all intention to make <add>in the way of utterance</add> undue profit by the article<lb/> | ||
so fabricated, it is not merely the mere circumstance of his knowing the mere consciousness knowledge | so fabricated, <del>it is not merely</del> <add>the mere circumstance of his knowing</add> the mere consciousness <add>knowledge</add><lb/> | ||
of its badness the article to be bad in the character of a shilling suffices | of its badness <add>the article to be <hi rend="underline">bad</hi></add> in the character of a shilling suffices<lb/> | ||
not of itself to warrant the attaching to it his consciousness that reproachful | not of itself to warrant the attaching to it <add>his consciousness</add> that reproachful<lb/> | ||
attribute. | attribute.</p> | ||
6 | <note>6<lb/> | ||
In fabrication case | In fabrication case<lb/> | ||
consciousness is not | <hi rend="underline">consciousness</hi> is not<lb/> | ||
evil, without evil | <hi rend="underline">evil</hi>, without evil<lb/> | ||
intention. | <hi rend="underline">intention</hi>.<lb/> | ||
Shilling bad — no intention | Shilling <add>bad</add> — no intention<lb/> | ||
to make undue | to make undue<lb/> | ||
profit of it, in the | profit of it, in the<lb/> | ||
consciousness of its | <hi rend="underline">consciousness</hi> of its<lb/> | ||
badness nothing evil. | badness nothing <hi rend="underline">evil</hi>.</note> | ||
In general this evilness of intention this | <p>In general this evilness of intention this<lb/> | ||
concomitant accompaniment of evil intention will not be wanting | <add>concomitant</add> accompaniment of evil intention will not be wanting<lb/> | ||
to the consciousness. But : but cases may put, nor those | to the consciousness. But <add>: but</add> cases may put, nor those<lb/> | ||
by any means unexampled ones, in which the intention to the intention | by any means unexampled ones, in which the intention <add>to the intention</add><lb/> | ||
no such reproachful spillins has justly been attributable | has not been <hi rend="underline">evil</hi> <add>no such reproachful <unclear>spillins</unclear> has justly been attributable</add>.</p> | ||
7 | <note>7<lb/> | ||
Generalities <gap/> | <hi rend="underline">Generalities</hi> <gap/><lb/> | ||
seriousness of the badness | seriousness of the badness<lb/> | ||
present, evil intention | present, evil intention<lb/> | ||
will not be absent. | will <hi rend="underline">not</hi> be absent.<lb/> | ||
But in particular | But in particular<lb/> | ||
cases, yes | cases, <hi rend="underline">yes</hi></note> | ||
1. The intention in which it was made, was that | <p>1. The <hi rend="underline">intention</hi> in which it was made, was that<lb/> | ||
of serving for a button: that it bears a certain degree degree | of serving for a <hi rend="underline">button</hi>: that it bears a certain degree <add>degree</add><lb/> | ||
of resemblance to many a piece of metal which <gap/> | of resemblance to many a piece of metal which <del><gap/></del><lb/> | ||
is in the habit of being passed for a shilling is a circumstance | is in the habit of being passed for a shilling is a circumstance<lb/> | ||
of which he is not unconscious: but <gap/> that it | of which he is not unconscious: but <del><gap/></del> that it<lb/> | ||
should be passed as such either by himself or by any | should be passed as such either by himself or by any<lb/> | ||
other person, was a circumstance result that in the intention of the man had never | other person, was a circumstance <add>result</add> that <add>in the intention of the man</add> had never<lb/> | ||
entered into his intention had never found a place. By accident, it finds its | entered into his intention <add>had <unclear>never</unclear> found a place</add>. By accident, it finds its<lb/> | ||
way into | way into hands, by <add>in</add> which, with or without the circumstance<lb/> | ||
of evil consciousness with or without the circumstance of culpable blamable | of evil consciousness with or without the circumstance of <del>culpable</del> <add>blamable</add><lb/> | ||
ignorance or attention it has obtains currency in that character. | ignorance or attention it has <add>obtains</add> currency in that character.</p> | ||
8 | <note>8<lb/> | ||
Example 1. Button. | Example 1. <hi rend="underline">Button</hi>.<lb/> | ||
Resemblance of a plain | Resemblance of a plain<lb/> | ||
button to | button to d<hi rend="superscript">o</hi> shilling<lb/> | ||
known to fabricator, | known to fabricator,<lb/> | ||
yet to pass it for such | yet to pass it for such<lb/> | ||
was not his intention. | was not his intention.<lb/> | ||
By accident, with or | By accident, with or<lb/> | ||
without negligence on | without negligence on<lb/> | ||
his part, it fell into | his part, it fell into<lb/> | ||
the hands of an Utterer | the hands of an Utterer<lb/> | ||
who passed it. | who passed it.<lb/> | ||
Utterer (who to be so | Utterer (who to be so<lb/> | ||
must first have been acceptor) | must first have been <hi rend="underline">acceptor</hi>)<lb/> | ||
may in | may in such<lb/> | ||
character have | character have been<lb/> | ||
evilly-conscious or not, | evilly-conscious or not,<lb/> | ||
and if not, h<gap/> | and if not, h<gap/><lb/> | ||
(thence blamable | (thence blamable)<lb/> | ||
or unblameable. | or unblameable.</note> | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} |
6 Aug 1811 4
Fallacies
Generalia
Ch. Parts bearable
4
In the case of the fabricator, a correspondent intention —
an intention to which the same attribute evil may
with propriety be applied, is implied when that same
attribute is applied to the subject of consciousness.
On the part of the fabricator in the case of the bad shilling suppose the absence
of all intention to make in the way of utterance undue profit by the article
so fabricated, it is not merely the mere circumstance of his knowing the mere consciousness knowledge
of its badness the article to be bad in the character of a shilling suffices
not of itself to warrant the attaching to it his consciousness that reproachful
attribute.
6
In fabrication case
consciousness is not
evil, without evil
intention.
Shilling bad — no intention
to make undue
profit of it, in the
consciousness of its
badness nothing evil.
In general this evilness of intention this
concomitant accompaniment of evil intention will not be wanting
to the consciousness. But : but cases may put, nor those
by any means unexampled ones, in which the intention to the intention
has not been evil no such reproachful spillins has justly been attributable.
7
Generalities
seriousness of the badness
present, evil intention
will not be absent.
But in particular
cases, yes
1. The intention in which it was made, was that
of serving for a button: that it bears a certain degree degree
of resemblance to many a piece of metal which
is in the habit of being passed for a shilling is a circumstance
of which he is not unconscious: but that it
should be passed as such either by himself or by any
other person, was a circumstance result that in the intention of the man had never
entered into his intention had never found a place. By accident, it finds its
way into hands, by in which, with or without the circumstance
of evil consciousness with or without the circumstance of culpable blamable
ignorance or attention it has obtains currency in that character.
8
Example 1. Button.
Resemblance of a plain
button to do shilling
known to fabricator,
yet to pass it for such
was not his intention.
By accident, with or
without negligence on
his part, it fell into
the hands of an Utterer
who passed it.
Utterer (who to be so
must first have been acceptor)
may in such
character have been
evilly-conscious or not,
and if not, h
(thence blamable)
or unblameable.
Identifier: | JB/104/085/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 104. |
|||
---|---|---|---|
1811-08-06 |
6-8 |
||
104 |
fallacies |
||
085 |
fallacies |
||
001 |
|||
text sheet |
1 |
||
recto |
d4 / e4 |
||
jeremy bentham |
|||
34056 |
|||