★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
human <add>opposition</add> Obstacles —</note> I must confess myself unable to form a clear Idea of Possession as distinguished on the<lb/> | human <add>opposition</add> Obstacles —</note> I must confess myself unable to form a clear Idea of Possession as distinguished on the<lb/> | ||
<note>3. Right Defensible on a contrary<lb/> | <note>3. Right Defensible on a contrary<lb/> | ||
of a permanent title - Right of Possession </note> | of a permanent title - Right of Possession </note> one hand from Right a moral <del><gap/></del> Relation [between a person & a thing] & on the oth<lb/> | ||
<note>4 Right indefensible</note>actual occupancy, a physical one.</p> | <note>4 Right indefensible</note> actual occupancy, a physical one.</p> | ||
<p>If then it be taken in the first Sense, it is <add>belongs to </add> <unclear>predirable</unclear> <add>as well</add> of a man, whom he has <del>permitted</del><add><gap/></add><lb/> | <p>If then it be taken in the first Sense, it is <add>belongs to </add> <unclear>predirable</unclear> <add>as well</add> of a man, whom he has <del>permitted</del><add><gap/></add><lb/> | ||
<gap/> to a | <gap/> to a Friend,as where to his Groom.</p> | ||
<p> <note>Whose property <add>charged</add>? <del><gap/></del>}Midd. Journ. Apr. 18.-20 1772}<lb/> | <p> <note>Whose property <add>charged</add>? <del><gap/></del><lb/> | ||
} Midd. Journ. Apr. 18.-20 1772}<lb/> | |||
Williams convicted at the last Shrewsbury}<lb/> | Williams convicted at the last Shrewsbury}<lb/> | ||
Assizes of stealing a chit box}<lb/> | Assizes of stealing a chit box}<lb/> | ||
containing £100 <gap/> < | containing £100 received <gap/>}<lb/> | ||
of Death, but rep<gap/>ed for transportation - } | of Death, but rep<gap/>ed for transportation - }<lb/> | ||
S<hi rend="superscript">r</hi> <gap/> for theft}</note> If in the latter, I see not how <add>with what propriety</add> it can be predicated of a man who is in London with<lb/> | S<hi rend="superscript">r</hi> <gap/> for theft}</note> If in the latter, I see not how <add>with what propriety</add> it can be predicated of a man who is in London with<lb/> | ||
respect to a Home which he has in Yorkshire</p> | respect to a Home which he has in Yorkshire</p> | ||
Line 44: | Line 45: | ||
because that may belong all the while [exclusively] to somebody else — I answer that <add>is</add><lb/> | because that may belong all the while [exclusively] to somebody else — I answer that <add>is</add><lb/> | ||
the a right at the time, which the man and he only who holds by what it called<lb/> | the a right at the time, which the man and he only who holds by what it called<lb/> | ||
possessing Title, exclusively is invested with | possessing Title, exclusively is invested with, to who has a right to corporal <gap/><lb/> | ||
by a writ of Right, not having the but only being to have it or not as the<lb/> | by a writ of Right, not having the but only being to have it or not as the<lb/> | ||
claim shall be determined or not in his favour</p> | claim shall be determined or not in his favour</p> | ||
<p>If possession does not mean the physical power agains{t}<lb/> | |||
all obstacles which can be opposed from man of making use of the thing whenever he <add>will</add><lb/> | |||
I must confess I understand not what it does but this power over the <add>House</add> <gap/>sellars by the<lb/> | |||
supposition no longer <gap/> where the Butler<add>Groom</add> has run away with them<add>it</add>.</p> | |||
<note>3. Counts - 1. for Goods of a person<lb/> | <note>3. Counts - 1. for Goods of a person<lb/> | ||
Line 53: | Line 59: | ||
In our case it seems ha has only<lb/> | In our case it seems ha has only<lb/> | ||
the custody, in the other the possession<lb/> | the custody, in the other the possession<lb/> | ||
now of a man being a <add>couple of</add>pair of Salt-Sellers & <gap/> | now of a man being a <add>couple of</add>pair of Salt-Sellers & <gap/> one of <add>pair</add> <del><gap/></del> to his Country House<lb/> | ||
and another to an acquaintance to keep<lb/> | and another to an acquaintance to keep<lb/> | ||
for him<lb/> | for him<lb/> | ||
Line 60: | Line 66: | ||
subsorts between a thing given &<lb/> | subsorts between a thing given &<lb/> | ||
the <del>Servant of him who has bought</del><add>Butler & the 1<hi rend="superscript">st</hi> Saltsellers</add><lb/> | the <del>Servant of him who has bought</del><add>Butler & the 1<hi rend="superscript">st</hi> Saltsellers</add><lb/> | ||
<del>it said put | <del>it said put it in his House</del><lb/> | ||
The Custody, and that which subsorts<lb/> | The Custody, and that which subsorts<lb/> | ||
<del>when</del> between <del>this</del> Stiles and the<lb/> | <del>when</del> between <del>this</del> Stiles and the<lb/> | ||
other Saltsellers, the possession<lb/> | other Saltsellers, the possession<lb/> | ||
[is what every man that | [is what every man that pleases has<lb/> | ||
an unquestioned right to do] <add><gap/> this</add> but<lb/> | an unquestioned right to do] <add><gap/> this</add> but<lb/> | ||
unless two <add>clear &</add> distinct Ideas can be<lb/> | unless two <add>clear &</add> distinct Ideas can be<lb/> | ||
found [out] for these two distinct<lb/> | found [out] for these two distinct<lb/> | ||
bounds, much <add>I shall</add> will not be<lb/> | bounds, much <add>I shall</add> will not be gained<lb/> | ||
we shall not be much the worse for <lb/> | we shall not be much the worse for <lb/> | ||
by the | by the distinction.<lb/> | ||
Let us therefore | Let us therefore examine what we<lb/> | ||
can mean when we speak of <add>a</add> possession<lb/>and what we can mean when we<lb/> | can mean when we speak of <add>a</add> possession<lb/> | ||
and what we can mean when we<lb/> | |||
speak of a custody, and see whether<lb/> | speak of a custody, and see whether<lb/> | ||
we can find any thing different <add>relative</add> to mean<lb/> | we can find any thing different <add>relative</add> to mean<lb/> | ||
with the | with the latter in our mouths than we meant with the former.</note><lb/> | ||
<note>That is <unclear>possibly</unclear> the | <note>That is <unclear>possibly</unclear> the same relation, and no more }<lb/>to be turned into two different ones by calling }<lb/> | ||
it in the one case "custody". Give the other possession }<lb/> | it in the one case "custody". Give the other possession }<lb/> | ||
than shooting can be <gap/> <add>split</add> into two different }<lb/> | than shooting can be <gap/> <add>split</add> into two different }<lb/> | ||
Line 86: | Line 93: | ||
<note> N.B. The Friend may }<lb/> | <note> N.B. The Friend may }<lb/> | ||
<gap/> the things given }<lb/> | <gap/> the things given }<lb/> | ||
him that the | him that the Servant }<lb/> | ||
cannot will. }</note><lb/> | cannot will. }</note><lb/> | ||
<note>N.B.<lb/> | <note>N.B.<lb/> | ||
Line 93: | Line 100: | ||
Master - v. some <gap/><lb/> | Master - v. some <gap/><lb/> | ||
I believe it is the ca<lb/> | I believe it is the ca<lb/> | ||
in Honour - it is <gap/> | in Honour - it is <gap/><lb/> | ||
down clearly.</note><lb/> | down clearly.</note><lb/> | ||
LARCENY EMBEZZLEMENT
The standing of a civil action will
always be regardedreceived as conclusive
of conness of Title
In the 1st Case, he has it not in both
In the second he had it in both cases
till the act of Embezzlement
In the 3d he has it in both
When The distinction being made between 1. Physical faculty in <add>actual</add> exercise 2d Physical faculty [against human obstacles opposite act in in] and leg
right, I see not what other the subject division at this stage can afford — Legal right itself is indeed
of a number ofdivisions — one of which for instance may be this which is given to it in virtue of it's being limited uncertainly in pe
of time — The right legal of possession which lawyers speak of, as contradistinct to the rig
to the thing itself, which a man by a<add> in<add>exception</add></add> Action of ment Writ of Possession<add>executed</add> Ejectment is indeed nothing but but a right to the thing itself deable dpositively
1. Faculty actually exercised
actually enjoyment any other ejectment defeasable indefinitively by aperpetual Injunction or Writ of Right. — It is the same
Relative differently modified in point of time.
2 Faculty not exercised - against
human opposition Obstacles — I must confess myself unable to form a clear Idea of Possession as distinguished on the
3. Right Defensible on a contrary
of a permanent title - Right of Possession one hand from Right a moral Relation [between a person & a thing] & on the oth
4 Right indefensible actual occupancy, a physical one.
If then it be taken in the first Sense, it is belongs to predirable as well of a man, whom he has permitted
to a Friend,as where to his Groom.
Whose property charged?
} Midd. Journ. Apr. 18.-20 1772}
Williams convicted at the last Shrewsbury}
Assizes of stealing a chit box}
containing £100 received }
of Death, but reped for transportation - }
Sr for theft} If in the latter, I see not how with what propriety it can be predicated of a man who is in London with
respect to a Home which he has in Yorkshire
It may here be saidanswer'd that the possession of im-moveables recoverable by a Civil Action that
of which we have a clear Idea - and it is not the same as al pence because
a man has it having at one end of the Kingdom of an Estate at the other. end of their Kingdom and it is nor is it not the same as aright
because that may belong all the while [exclusively] to somebody else — I answer that is
the a right at the time, which the man and he only who holds by what it called
possessing Title, exclusively is invested with, to who has a right to corporal
by a writ of Right, not having the but only being to have it or not as the
claim shall be determined or not in his favour
If possession does not mean the physical power agains{t}
all obstacles which can be opposed from man of making use of the thing whenever he will
I must confess I understand not what it does but this power over the House sellars by the
supposition no longer where the ButlerGroom has run away with themit.
3. Counts - 1. for Goods of a person
unknown - 2. for the Landlord
of the House - 3 for
In our case it seems ha has only
the custody, in the other the possession
now of a man being a couple ofpair of Salt-Sellers & one of pair to his Country House
and another to an acquaintance to keep
for him
Every man is of unquestionably
of liberty to call that Relation that
subsorts between a thing given &
the Servant of him who has boughtButler & the 1st Saltsellers
it said put it in his House
The Custody, and that which subsorts
when between this Stiles and the
other Saltsellers, the possession
[is what every man that pleases has
an unquestioned right to do] this but
unless two clear & distinct Ideas can be
found [out] for these two distinct
bounds, much I shall will not be gained
we shall not be much the worse for
by the distinction.
Let us therefore examine what we
can mean when we speak of a possession
and what we can mean when we
speak of a custody, and see whether
we can find any thing different relative to mean
with the latter in our mouths than we meant with the former.
That is possibly the same relation, and no more }
to be turned into two different ones by calling }
it in the one case "custody". Give the other possession }
than shooting can be split into two different }
acts by resolving to call it by that name
wheresoever a man's name who is at apparent to be }
The Simon, & giving it the name of passing }
when his name is Peter. }
N.B. The Friend may }
the things given }
him that the Servant }
cannot will. }
N.B.
A Servant has the righ
against all but his
Master - v. some
I believe it is the ca
in Honour - it is
down clearly.
EMBEZZLT [BR][4] Right x Possession x Custody.
Identifier: | JB/070/225/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 70. |
|||
---|---|---|---|
070 |
of laws in general |
||
225 |
embezzlement |
||
001 |
right & possession & custody |
||
text sheet |
1 |
||
recto |
|||
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::gr [crown motif] [britannia with shield motif]]] |
||
23340 |
|||