★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
talk to <unclear>them</unclear> to separate them : <del><unclear>It</unclear></del> actual exercise , usually | talk to <unclear>them</unclear> to separate them : <del><unclear>It</unclear></del> actual exercise , usually | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
when unopposed <gap/><!-- symbol, or addition not added ? --> <del> | when unopposed <gap/><!-- symbol, or addition not added ? --> <del>by</del> affords a good presumptive proof | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
of right of exercise a good , and just ground of presumption , | of right of exercise a good , and just ground of presumption , | ||
| Line 28: | Line 28: | ||
<p><!-- indented -->By <add>In</add> the opinion actually given by them <del><gap/></del> by the | <p><!-- indented -->By <add>In</add> the opinion actually given by them <del><gap/></del> by the | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
opinion as it stands worded no express | opinion as it stands worded no express affirmance | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
is | is contained of the right of the thing to legislate | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
over <del>the</del> Colonies [in the <add>particular</add> case in question to legislate in | over <del>the</del> Colonies [in the <add>particular</add> case in question to legislate in | ||
| Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
is — that by their opinion , <del>or be</del> [judging from <add>of</add> it by | is — that by their opinion , <del>or be</del> [judging from <add>of</add> it by | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
so much of it as is given <add> | so much of it as is given <add>recited</add> by Lord Mansfield in that | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
case ] they do <add>did</add> not . <add>affirm it</add> All that is said is that if a | case ] they do <add>did</add> not . <add>affirm it</add> All that is said is that if a | ||
| Line 56: | Line 56: | ||
of each other - but without saying which <add>expressly</add> : but probably | of each other - but without saying which <add>expressly</add> : but probably | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
the meaning was that each of <unclear>these</unclear><!-- or, 'those' --> | the meaning was that each of <unclear>these</unclear><!-- or, 'those' --> modes was a valid | ||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
mode since that by an Assembly of the island had been | |||
<lb/> | <lb/> | ||
<add><del><gap/></del> at any rate the</add> most <gap/> <del>if not the only one <gap/></del> and it | <add><del><gap/></del> at any rate the</add> most <gap/> <del>if not the only one <gap/></del> and it | ||
06-Jul-2012: under construction by Diane Folan. Please do not amend.
24 July 1802
N. S. Wales. Conduct
35 III . Non-exist. proved
of theirs to start one . In this case as in other cases
of possession , fact and right go together till something
talk to them to separate them : It actual exercise , usually
when unopposed by affords a good presumptive proof
of right of exercise a good , and just ground of presumption ,
until some special cause comes in to do
it away repel it.
By In the opinion actually given by them by the
opinion as it stands worded no express affirmance
is contained of the right of the thing to legislate
over the Colonies [in the particular case in question to legislate in
the way of ] without Parliament . I do not
take upon me so say they would not have affirmed
it had the question been put to them - all I say
is — that by their opinion , or be [judging from of it by
so much of it as is given recited by Lord Mansfield in that
case ] they do did not . affirm it All that is said is that if a
tax can be imposed upon the inhabitants of these Colonies
to be legally imposed it must be imposed "by an
asembly of the island , or by an Act of Parliament , i:e:
in one or other of these ways , exclusively or not exclusively
of each other - but without saying which expressly : but probably
the meaning was that each of these modes was a valid
mode since that by an Assembly of the island had been
at any rate the most if not the only one and it
entered not for any thing that appears into the conception
of either party at that time to dispute the right of Parliament .
|
Identifier: | JB/116/148/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 116. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
1802-07-24 |
|||
|
116 |
panopticon versus new south wales |
||
|
148 |
n. s. wales |
||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
e5 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::[monogram] 1800]] |
||
|
1800 |
|||
|
37681 |
|||
