JB/096/026/001: Difference between revisions

Transcribe Bentham: A Collaborative Initiative

From Transcribe Bentham: Transcription Desk

Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts

JB/096/026/001: Difference between revisions

Diane Folan (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
TB Editor (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 4: Line 4:


<p><note><hi rend='underline'>To be copied</hi></note>&amp; yet till it is notified it wants one essential
<p><note><hi rend='underline'>To be copied</hi></note>&amp; yet till it is notified it wants one essential
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
property of a Law.<add>#</add></p>
                    property of a Law.<add>#</add></p>
 
               
<p><del>as before our Author mistook the principles
                <p><del>as before our Author mistook the principles
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
<sic>imprest</sic> upon matter for Laws, so here he has <add>as we have</add>
                    <sic>imprest</sic> upon matter for Laws, so here he has <add>as we have</add>
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
seen at the end of the second Section he
                    seen at the end of the second Section he
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
again mistook a principle <sic>imprest</sic> upon
                    again mistook a principle <sic>imprest</sic> upon
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
man for a Law given to him.</del></p>
                    man for a Law given to him.</del></p>
 
               
<p>Our author's next <del>absurdity</del> <add>inconsequence</add> is making the law
                <p>Our author's next <del>absurdity</del> <add>inconsequence</add> is making the law
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
of Nature, (<del>which is a <sic>meer</sic> non entity</del>, &amp; the
                    of Nature, (<del>which is a <sic>meer</sic> non entity</del>, &amp; the
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
law of Revelation the <del>groundwork</del> <add>foundation</add> of all municipal
                    law of Revelation the <del>groundwork</del> <add>foundation</add> of all municipal
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
Law.  The Law of Nature we have shewn
                    Law.  The Law of Nature we have shewn
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
to be a <sic>meer</sic> creature of the Brain.  <del>And</del> As
                    to be a <sic>meer</sic> creature of the Brain.  <del>And</del> As
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
to that principle <add>of the desire of happiness</add> which he mistakes for a
                    to that principle <add>of the desire of happiness</add> which he mistakes for a
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
Law, <add>it its certain</add> no human Law <del>given ever did, our</del> <add>ought to oppose it</add>
                    Law, <add>it its certain</add> no human Law <del>given ever did, our</del> <add>ought to oppose it</add>
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
<del>ever could</del> <add><del>mean to</del></add> go against it <add>Nor indeed did ever any human legislator <sic>propperly</sic></add>.  The greatest tyrant
                    <del>ever could</del> <add><del>mean to</del></add> go against it <add>Nor indeed did ever any human legislator <sic>propperly</sic></add>.  The greatest tyrant
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
when he intones the most tyrannical Law,  
                    when he intones the most tyrannical Law,  
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
<del>as does not me it, </del> <add>so far from opposing this principle</add> applies to it: &amp; demands obedience
                    <del>as does not me it, </del> <add>so far from opposing this principle</add> applies to it: &amp; demands obedience
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
by proving that obedience will produce
                    by proving that obedience will produce
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
the greatest quantity of happiness: &amp; if he cannot
                    the greatest quantity of happiness: &amp; if he cannot
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
persuade a man to think so he is sure to be
                    persuade a man to think so he is sure to be
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
disobeyed. &#x2014; <del>He the Jackal, a tyrant does</del> <add>In a state of nature <del>this</del> each</add>
                    disobeyed. &#x2014; <del>He the Jackal, a tyrant does</del> <add>In a state of nature <del>this</del> each</add>
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
<add><del>But</del></add> <del>not so much offend against the principle <add>of</del></add> <add>individual, unconnected with others: can easily discern <add>what</add></add>
                    <add><del>But</del></add> <del>not so much offend against the principle </del><add>of</add> <add>individual, unconnected with others: can easily discern <add>what</add></add>
</p>
                </p>
<!-- horizontal line -->
                <!-- horizontal line -->
 
               
<p><add>#</add> The intelligent reader will not consider this
                <p><add>#</add> The intelligent reader will not consider this
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
distinction between a <hi rend='underline'>Law</hi> &amp; a <hi rend='underline'>principle</hi> as a  
                    distinction between a <hi rend='underline'>Law</hi> &amp; a <hi rend='underline'>principle</hi> as a  
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
<sic>mear</sic> dispute about words. Or if he does
                    <sic>mear</sic> dispute about words. Or if he does
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
he will conclude with D<hi rend='superscript'>r</hi> Brown "that a history
                    he will conclude with D<hi rend='superscript'>r</hi> Brown "that a history
<lb/>  
                    <lb/>  
"of Logomachies well executed would be no unedifying  
                    "of Logomachies well executed would be no unedifying  
<lb/>
                    <lb/>
work."<note>Essay on Characteristics  Essay. II. Sect. ii.</note></p>
                    work."<note>Essay on Characteristics  Essay. II. Sect. ii.</note></p>
 
               
<head><del>23</del> 71</head>
                <head><del>23</del> 71</head>
 
               


<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE -->
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}

Revision as of 14:25, 18 March 2011

Click Here To Edit


To be copied& yet till it is notified it wants one essential
property of a Law.#

as before our Author mistook the principles
imprest upon matter for Laws, so here he has as we have
seen at the end of the second Section he
again mistook a principle imprest upon
man for a Law given to him.

Our author's next absurdity inconsequence is making the law
of Nature, (which is a meer non entity, & the
law of Revelation the groundwork foundation of all municipal
Law. The Law of Nature we have shewn
to be a meer creature of the Brain. And As
to that principle of the desire of happiness which he mistakes for a
Law, it its certain no human Law given ever did, our ought to oppose it
ever could mean to go against it Nor indeed did ever any human legislator propperly. The greatest tyrant
when he intones the most tyrannical Law,
as does not me it, so far from opposing this principle applies to it: & demands obedience
by proving that obedience will produce
the greatest quantity of happiness: & if he cannot
persuade a man to think so he is sure to be
disobeyed. — He the Jackal, a tyrant does In a state of nature this each
But not so much offend against the principle of individual, unconnected with others: can easily discern <add>what</add>

# The intelligent reader will not consider this
distinction between a Law & a principle as a
mear dispute about words. Or if he does
he will conclude with Dr Brown "that a history
"of Logomachies well executed would be no unedifying
work."Essay on Characteristics Essay. II. Sect. ii.

               23 71
               



Identifier: | JB/096/026/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 96.

Date_1

Marginal Summary Numbering

Box

096

Main Headings

comment on the commentaries

Folio number

026

Info in main headings field

Image

001

Titles

note

Category

collectanea

Number of Pages

1

Recto/Verso

recto

Page Numbering

c71

Penner

168

Watermarks

[[watermarks::[gr with crown]]]

Marginals

Paper Producer

Corrections

Paper Produced in Year

Notes public

[[notes_public::"to be copied" [note not in bentham's hand]]]

ID Number

31030

Box Contents

UCL Home » Transcribe Bentham » Transcription Desk
  • Create account
  • Log in