★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
<!-- this page is divided into two columns each with a margin to the left --> <head>MISCHIEF. Power of APPREHENSION wanting <lb/> <!-- under the word wanting -->proposed <gap/></head> <p> <add> | <!-- this page is divided into two columns each with a margin to the left --> <head>MISCHIEF. Power of APPREHENSION wanting <lb/> <!-- under the word wanting -->proposed <gap/></head> <p> <add>Under</add> In the Offence of Mischief whether Mischievous<lb/> or Wanton <hi rend="superscript">+</hi> <note>+ or even accidental<lb/> under certain<lb/> restrictions — especially<lb/> if negligent.<lb/> <gap/> for <gap/><lb/> One of the questions<lb/> to the Jury is a<lb/>notion of false arrest<lb/>on this ground may<lb/> be <!-- blank space --> did the <sic>Deft</sic> appear<lb/> as not a responsible<lb/> person?</note> only there wants a power <del>of apprehension</del><lb/> <add><del>as</del></add> for persons at large of <hi rend="underline">apprehending</hi><lb/>offenders detected in the past. The common<lb/> objection <add>is</add> <del>in these cases is</del>, that it <add>such a power in these cases</add> is too <lb/> great a restraint <add> <gap/></add> upon liberty, & <del>giving powers</del><lb/> that <del>are</del> <add> it would be very</add> liable to be abused. But [it should be<lb/> <sic>consider'd</sic>] this is giving no more physical<lb/> power <del>than</del> <add> to any</add> man than he had before:<lb/> without such a power as well as with it,<lb/> any man may carry off any other to a Magistrate<lb/> or any where else that is not strong<lb/> enough to resist him — All that it does<lb/> is to provide is in the first place that the<lb/> Magistrate would be enabled to do in 5 cases the<lb/> Justice he would wish to do and all, <del> instead of</del> <add> to</add> one and<lb/> which he could have done it before ——<lb/> in the next, that if it should come out, upon any<lb/> action brought for false imprisonment that<lb/> the arrest was for <del>this</del> contributing in this way<lb/> to the execution of Justice, the arrestor would<lb/> <note>if it were,</note> not be punished <add> <del> if it was paid</del> with it</add> after such a power given, as</p> <pb/> <!-- right hand column --><p> he would || <note>|| without it</note> if it were not.</p> <p> But Motive or Interest it may be still but<lb/> said, will <add>may</add> take advantage of some petty<lb/> <sic>tho'</sic> real mischief <hi rend="superscript">+</hi> <note>+ Damage</note> to work by means of<lb/> this power, a substantive injury: as in the<lb/> instance where the offender may be a <lb/> <unclear>Seaman</unclear> obliged to be on board his vessel<lb/> at a certain time, or else lose his voyage.<lb/> To this <del> again <add> it may be</add> <gap/> assumed that</del> may<lb/> be obviated by providing that if the mischief <add> damage</add> <lb/> be <del>a</del> trifling and the ill consequence to the<lb/> offender so great <del><gap/></del> ( & this notified to the arrester)<lb/> that it may be presumed it was the working<lb/> of this injury & not the procuring compensation<lb/> from the trespasser that was the motive<lb/> to the arrest, the party arrested may<lb/> be entitled to such damages as a Jury <del>would</del> <add>will</add> <lb/> give just as if the arrest was without<lb/> pretence.</p> <p> It is to be observed that no arrest which can<lb/> appear to have been made for the purpose<lb/> of carrying the party to justice before a Magistrate<lb/> & consequently come under this justification, can<lb/> well continue so long as 24 hours: as <gap/> <add> without</add></p> <!-- line across the page --> <head> Loose Hints.</head> <p> Compare this with other cases <sic>were</sic> arrest is given<lb/> by Common Law or Statute.</p> <!-- line across the page --><p> time viz: when the parties are before the Magistrate<lb/> it will appear whether the arrest<lb/> is fit to be continued</p> <p>Now for an Imprisonment without any such excuse,<lb/> for no longer time than this <del> very small</del> <add> no very</add> <lb/> considerable damage would be given, unless<lb/> proof of the <add>aggravating</add> circumstance [we are speaking of]<lb/> would be given: & if <add>where</add> it is case, then the power<lb/> ceases to be an excuse.</p> <!-- at the bottom of the page on the left --> <p>MISCHIEF. Power of Apprehension wanting. [BR][4]</p> | ||
MISCHIEF. Power of APPREHENSION wanting
proposed
Under In the Offence of Mischief whether Mischievous
or Wanton + + or even accidental
under certain
restrictions — especially
if negligent.
for
One of the questions
to the Jury is a
notion of false arrest
on this ground may
be did the Deft appear
as not a responsible
person? only there wants a power of apprehension
as for persons at large of apprehending
offenders detected in the past. The common
objection is in these cases is, that it such a power in these cases is too
great a restraint upon liberty, & giving powers
that are it would be very liable to be abused. But [it should be
consider'd] this is giving no more physical
power than to any man than he had before:
without such a power as well as with it,
any man may carry off any other to a Magistrate
or any where else that is not strong
enough to resist him — All that it does
is to provide is in the first place that the
Magistrate would be enabled to do in 5 cases the
Justice he would wish to do and all, instead of to one and
which he could have done it before ——
in the next, that if it should come out, upon any
action brought for false imprisonment that
the arrest was for this contributing in this way
to the execution of Justice, the arrestor would
if it were, not be punished if it was paid with it after such a power given, as
---page break---
he would || || without it if it were not.
But Motive or Interest it may be still but
said, will may take advantage of some petty
tho' real mischief + + Damage to work by means of
this power, a substantive injury: as in the
instance where the offender may be a
Seaman obliged to be on board his vessel
at a certain time, or else lose his voyage.
To this again it may be assumed that may
be obviated by providing that if the mischief damage
be a trifling and the ill consequence to the
offender so great ( & this notified to the arrester)
that it may be presumed it was the working
of this injury & not the procuring compensation
from the trespasser that was the motive
to the arrest, the party arrested may
be entitled to such damages as a Jury would will
give just as if the arrest was without
pretence.
It is to be observed that no arrest which can
appear to have been made for the purpose
of carrying the party to justice before a Magistrate
& consequently come under this justification, can
well continue so long as 24 hours: as without
Loose Hints.
Compare this with other cases were arrest is given
by Common Law or Statute.
time viz: when the parties are before the Magistrate
it will appear whether the arrest
is fit to be continued
Now for an Imprisonment without any such excuse,
for no longer time than this very small no very
considerable damage would be given, unless
proof of the aggravating circumstance [we are speaking of]
would be given: & if where it is case, then the power
ceases to be an excuse.
MISCHIEF. Power of Apprehension wanting. [BR][4]
|
Identifier: | JB/070/277/002"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 70. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
070 |
of laws in general |
||
|
277 |
mischief - power of apprehension wanting |
||
|
002 |
|||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
|||
|
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::gr [crown motif] [lion with vryheyt motif]]] |
||
|
23392 |
|||
