★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
'''[{{fullurl:JB/159/042/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | '''[{{fullurl:JB/159/042/001|action=edit}} Click Here To Edit]''' | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
<head><!-- in pencil -->18 March 1811</head> | |||
<p>1. In some cases the object which <add>or at least one object</add>< | <p>1. In some cases the object which <add>or at least one object</add> <del>the <gap/></del> in the infliction<lb/> | ||
of the evil the man in power or some person <note>15<lb/> | of the evil the man in power or some person <note>15<lb/> | ||
i. <add>If</add> | i. <add>If</add> Production of evil<lb/> | ||
in consideration of<lb/> | in consideration of<lb/> | ||
evil sustained by<lb/> | evil sustained by<lb/> | ||
Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
<add>of some person or other, evil</add><del>of the person in question</del> in some shape or other<lb/> | <add>of some person or other, evil</add><del>of the person in question</del> in some shape or other<lb/> | ||
the object which he has in view in the infliction of<lb/> | the object which he has in view in the infliction of<lb/> | ||
the evil in question he has in view is an <del>certain</del> | the evil in question he has in view is an <del>certain</del><lb/> | ||
enjoyment a pleasure of a certain kind which he<lb/> | enjoyment a pleasure of a certain kind which he<lb/> | ||
derives or expects to derive from the contemplation of<lb/> | derives or expects to derive from the contemplation of<lb/> | ||
the evil thus sustained.</p> | the evil thus sustained.</p> | ||
<p>In this case the act in question is termed | <p>In this case the act in question is termed an<lb/> | ||
act of vengeance.</p> | act of vengeance.</p> | ||
<p>But besides being an act of vengeance - and not<lb/> | <p>But besides being an act of vengeance - and not<lb/> | ||
the less for being an act of vengeance | the less for being an act of vengeance it is not an act of<lb/> | ||
punishment.</p> | punishment.</p> | ||
<p><del>The evil thus provided is in the</del> So far as<lb/> | <p><del>The evil thus provided is in the</del> So far as<lb/> | ||
Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
intentional.</p> | intentional.</p> | ||
<p>Whether in the characters of a sole object a result of<lb/> | <p>Whether in the characters of a sole object a result of<lb/> | ||
this nature be a fit object for a<add>the</add> man in power to propose <note> | this nature be a fit object for a<add>the</add> man in power to propose <note><!-- Pencil note -->16<lb/> | ||
The result <unclear>must</unclear><lb/> | The result <unclear>must</unclear><lb/> | ||
or <unclear>musent</unclear>, the< | or <unclear>musent</unclear>, the<lb/> | ||
act is not the less<lb/> | act is not the less<lb/> | ||
d<hi rend="superscript">o</hi> of punishment<lb/> | d<hi rend="superscript">o</hi> of punishment<lb/> | ||
Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
this purpose</note><lb/> | this purpose</note><lb/> | ||
to himself is a <add>indeed</add> very important question <del>indeed</del> <add><del>a question</del></add> but one<lb/> | to himself is a <add>indeed</add> very important question <del>indeed</del> <add><del>a question</del></add> but one<lb/> | ||
which has no place here: punishment, by being misapplied <note>17<lb/> | which has no place here: punishment, by being misapplied <note><!-- Pencil note -->17<lb/> | ||
To a portion of punishment<lb/> | To a portion of punishment<lb/> | ||
inflicted for<lb/> | inflicted for<lb/> | ||
Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
is not the less punishment.</p> | is not the less punishment.</p> | ||
<p>If in a case in which in pursuit of some one or more<lb/> | <p>If in a case in which in pursuit of some one or more<lb/> | ||
of the objects of which | of the objects of which mention is about to be made, <add>to</add> a punishment<lb/> | ||
which to that purpose would have been considered as<lb/> | which to that purpose would have been considered as<lb/> | ||
sufficient <del>are <gap/></del> evil to an <gap/>larier amount be added, in this <add>supposition</add> <note>supposition we have <add>the case <del>afford</del><add>pre<gap/></add></add><lb/> | sufficient <del>are <gap/></del> evil to an <gap/>larier amount be added, in this <add>supposition</add> <note>supposition we have <add>the case <del>afford</del><add>pre<gap/></add></add><lb/> |
Click Here To Edit 18 March 1811
1. In some cases the object which or at least one object the in the infliction
of the evil the man in power or some person 15
i. If Production of evil
in consideration of
evil sustained by
the ultimate object
the act is an
act of vengeance:
- but not the less
an act of punishment
or persons having as he supposes receivedundergone at the hands
of some person or other, evilof the person in question in some shape or other
the object which he has in view in the infliction of
the evil in question he has in view is an certain
enjoyment a pleasure of a certain kind which he
derives or expects to derive from the contemplation of
the evil thus sustained.
In this case the act in question is termed an
act of vengeance.
But besides being an act of vengeance - and not
the less for being an act of vengeance it is not an act of
punishment.
The evil thus provided is in the So far as
this and this akin wasis his object the evil this produced
wasis not only directly intentional but ultimately
intentional.
Whether in the characters of a sole object a result of
this nature be a fit object for athe man in power to propose 16
The result must
or musent, the
act is not the less
do of punishment
Whether such
is fit ultimate object,
, not to
this purpose
to himself is a indeed very important question indeed a question but one
which has no place here: punishment, by being misapplied 17
To a portion of punishment
inflicted for
some other cases as
may be added and
for this cause
is not the less punishment.
If in a case in which in pursuit of some one or more
of the objects of which mention is about to be made, to a punishment
which to that purpose would have been considered as
sufficient are evil to an larier amount be added, in this supposition supposition we have the case afford<add>pre</add>
a complex operation
resolvable cuts consisting of two acts
of whichtheir having the
other object here supposed
leaves another which not having for its object any other than the gratification of the passion of vengeance is party to an act of vengeance.
Identifier: | JB/159/042/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 159. |
|||
---|---|---|---|
1811-03-01 |
15-17 |
||
159 |
punishment |
||
042 |
|||
001 |
|||
text sheet |
1 |
||
recto |
d6 / e6 |
||
jeremy bentham |
th 1806 |
||
andre morellet |
|||
1806 |
|||
53865 |
|||