★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
<note>where the persuasion <lb/>is already adopted</note> | <note>where the persuasion <lb/>is already adopted</note> | ||
<add>matter</add> it is not in the power of punishment to make <add>cause</add><lb/>him <add>really to</add> alter it is a proposition than which nothing<lb/>can be more incontestible <note>If any one should <del>be</del> <add>feel himself</add> disposed to <del>dispute</del> <add>doubt of</add> this, I would<lb/> propose to him the following experiment; if such it<lb/>may be called, where the facts in question <add>exemplified</add> in<lb/>the very | <add>matter</add> it is not in the power of punishment to make <add>cause</add><lb/>him <add>really to</add> alter it is a proposition than which nothing<lb/>can be more incontestible <note>If any one should <del>be</del> <add>feel himself</add> disposed to <del>dispute</del> <add>doubt of</add> this, I would<lb/> propose to him the following experiment; if such it<lb/>may be called, where the facts in question <add>exemplified</add> in<lb/>the very essence of them hypothetical. <del>Let him</del> <add>Go</add><lb/>into any room in which there is one <add>and but one</add> table: that<lb/> is what to <del>him</del> <add>you</add> after having examined it appears<lb/>to be one and but one table. Now <del>let him</del> <add><del>there</del></add> consider<lb/>whether if a man stronger than <del>himself</del> <add>you</add> were<lb/>to come and threaten <del>him</del> <add>you</add> that unless <del>he</del> <add>you</add> believed<lb/><lb/>that in that room instead of one table there were<lb/>four <add>three</add> <del>he</del> <add>you</add> should be soundly beaten, it would <add>could</add> be possible <lb/>for <del>that man</del> <add><del>you</del> that man</add> by all the beating he could give you to<lb/>cause you really to believe that in that room there were<lb/>really four tables. Or to come to a test which belongs more<lb/></note> It would rather confirm him in it: partly by the <gap/> <gap/> <add>of the want of reasons</add> which <gap/><lb/>so applied comes with it of the wantof reasons;<lb/>and partly by the aversion which it creates toward<lb/>that <add>the arguments of any which militate on that one</add> side of the question which it <del>the</del> supports:<lb/>The only point then which it is possible for punishment<lb/>when thus applied to compass, and indeed<lb/><add>in point of fact</add> the only point to the compassing of which punishment<lb/>has ever been applied is the obliging <add>causing</add> a man<lb/>to say <add><hi rend="underline">declare</hi></add> that he believes the proposition in question.<lb/> | ||
4
[Indirect Legislation]
Religion
where the persuasion
is already adopted
matter it is not in the power of punishment to make cause
him really to alter it is a proposition than which nothing
can be more incontestible If any one should be feel himself disposed to dispute doubt of this, I would
propose to him the following experiment; if such it
may be called, where the facts in question exemplified in
the very essence of them hypothetical. Let him Go
into any room in which there is one and but one table: that
is what to him you after having examined it appears
to be one and but one table. Now let him there consider
whether if a man stronger than himself you were
to come and threaten him you that unless he you believed
that in that room instead of one table there were
four three he you should be soundly beaten, it would could be possible
for that man you that man by all the beating he could give you to
cause you really to believe that in that room there were
really four tables. Or to come to a test which belongs more
It would rather confirm him in it: partly by the of the want of reasons which
so applied comes with it of the wantof reasons;
and partly by the aversion which it creates toward
that the arguments of any which militate on that one side of the question which it the supports:
The only point then which it is possible for punishment
when thus applied to compass, and indeed
in point of fact the only point to the compassing of which punishment
has ever been applied is the obliging causing a man
to say declare that he believes the proposition in question.
Identifier: | JB/087/020/004"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 87. |
|||
---|---|---|---|
1-6 |
|||
087 |
indirect legislation |
||
020 |
indirect legislation |
||
004 |
note |
||
text sheet |
4 |
||
recto |
f1 / f2 / f3 / f4 |
||
jeremy bentham |
[[watermarks::r williams [britannia with shield motif]]] |
||
c. hamilton |
|||
27545 |
|||