★ Find a new page on our Untranscribed Manuscripts list.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
<!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- ENTER TRANSCRIPTION BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
<!-- header in pencil --> | |||
<p>+ 19<lb/><note>Leading Points<lb/>Note B.</note></p> <p><del>The grounds of that disapprobation as stated upon<lb/><lb/>the fac</del></p> <p><del>— On a</del> <add>Two objections are there made —</add> 1. that such burning <del>been though</del> <add>being</add> intended<lb/>as a punishment is in <del>the character of a punishment</del><lb/>that point of view "<hi rend="underline">often disregarded and ineffectual</hi>."<lb/>The proposed identification-mark neither<lb/><del><gap/></del. <add>is</add> a punishment nor <add>is</add> intended <del>as a punishment,</del> <add>so to be.</add><lb/><del>does not fall within the censure</del></p> <p>— 2. <del>The other objective</del> that <del>it</del> <add><del>(burning in the hand) there the marking "may sometimes</add> <del>sometimes may</del><lb/>"fix a lasting mark of disgrace and infamy on<lb/>"offenders, who might otherwise become good subjects<lb/>"and profitable members of society" <hi rend="superscript">[+]</hi> <note><hi rend="superscript">[+]</hi> Here the <del>cause of<lb/>infamy</del> efficient causes<lb/>of the infamy produced<lb/>by <hi rend="underline">that</hi> mode of marking<lb/><del>have no existence<lb/>and as to the becoming<lb/>profitable members of<lb/>society, instead of<lb/>being, as in that case<lb/>it is obstructed, it<lb/>is secured</del><lb/><hi rend="underline">pain</hi> I mean and<lb/><hi rend="underline">exposure</hi> — (pain too<lb/>great not to be evidently<lb/>meant for punishment —<lb/>exposure<lb/>perpetual and unavoidable)<lb/>have no<lb/>existence. And as<lb/>to the becoming profitable<lb/>members of society, instead of<lb/>being as in that case<lb/><hi rend="underline">obstructed</hi>, it is <hi rend="underline">secured</hi>.</note> <!-- remainder of the page crossed though in ink -->The <del>point</del> <add>mischief</add><lb/><del>arrived at by this objection</del> <add>here is</add> not <add><del>I suppose</del></add> the effect it has<lb/>upon the <del>point</del> feelings of the <del><gap/></del> delinquents in<lb/>question, but in bad efforts which may be apprehended<lb/>from it <del>with regard</del> <add>in relation</add> to their future good<lb/>behaviour. Against <add>from</add> this objection the proposed identification<lb/>mark is guarded <add>stands clear</add> by every point of view<lb/><del>The <del>circumstances</del> that <add>of the two circumstances, (pain and constant exposure) that render <add>contribute to</add> <del>the</del> infamy an inevitable<lb/>consequence of that effective mode of marking<lb/><del>there is not one that</del> <add>neither</add> has any place in the<lb/>instance of this mild and innocent one.</p> <p><del>What constitutes the infamy</del></p> <p>The mode of producing the mark there meant<lb/>to be produced is not only a painful one, but perhaps<lb/>the most painful of any that could be devised: and<lb/>this <del.one</del> <add>mode</add> besides the corporal <del>suffering which it</del> <add>punishment it contains</add><lb/><del>within made of</del> <add>involves</add> adds to the infamy by the <del><gap/></del> <add>proof</add><lb/><add>it</add></p> | |||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{ | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}}{{In_Progress}} | ||
+ 19
Leading Points
Note B.
The grounds of that disapprobation as stated upon
the fac
— On a Two objections are there made — 1. that such burning been though being intended
as a punishment is in the character of a punishment
that point of view "often disregarded and ineffectual."
The proposed identification-mark neither
</del. is a punishment nor is intended as a punishment, so to be.
does not fall within the censure
— 2. The other objective that it (burning in the hand) there the marking "may sometimes sometimes may
"fix a lasting mark of disgrace and infamy on
"offenders, who might otherwise become good subjects
"and profitable members of society" [+] [+] Here the cause of
infamy efficient causes
of the infamy produced
by that mode of marking
have no existence
and as to the becoming
profitable members of
society, instead of
being, as in that case
it is obstructed, it
is secured
pain I mean and
exposure — (pain too
great not to be evidently
meant for punishment —
exposure
perpetual and unavoidable)
have no
existence. And as
to the becoming profitable
members of society, instead of
being as in that case
obstructed, it is secured. The point mischief
arrived at by this objection here is not I suppose the effect it has
upon the point feelings of the delinquents in
question, but in bad efforts which may be apprehended
from it with regard in relation to their future good
behaviour. Against from this objection the proposed identification
mark is guarded stands clear by every point of view
The circumstances that of the two circumstances, (pain and constant exposure) that render <add>contribute to the infamy an inevitable
consequence of that effective mode of marking
there is not one that neither has any place in the
instance of this mild and innocent one.
What constitutes the infamy
The mode of producing the mark there meant
to be produced is not only a painful one, but perhaps
the most painful of any that could be devised: and
this <del.one mode besides the corporal suffering which it punishment it contains
within made of involves adds to the infamy by the proof
it
|
Identifier: | JB/124/017/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 124. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
124 |
panopticon |
||
|
017 |
|||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
2 |
||
|
recto |
d19 / d20 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
|||
|
41706 |
|||
