JB/079/136/001

Click Here To Edit

PERSONS at LargeSECT XII.

ART. III Whose maliciously committed mischief by plucking
up, pulling down or destroying [in whole or in part,]
[finished or unfinished,] any of the works following:
viz.[1] any Turnpike Weighing - Engine; or [2]any Turnpike
Toll-gate or other fence set up to prevent persons
from passing without paying Toll; or [3] any Turnpike
Toll-House; shall be deemed guilty of Felony, and
shall suffer death as a Felon without benefit of Clergy.

Observations [And to prevent & c. .....O.] Another Preamble forose who might the
instruction of those who might not otherwise have found
out that the punishing of an offence with death, was
meant for its' prevention.

If there be one case more than another in which
we are entitled to expect precision it is where as here, the
thread of life hangs upon a word. Pleonarins
accordingly (which are the Statute currency for precision)
are accordingly got together with in more than ordinary
quantity, and with the ordinary effect.

[... Willfully or maliciously ...O.] In the 1st place
"willfully" is included in "maliciously": therefore it
is of no use. In the 2nd place, the "or" is either
disjunctive making the passage to man "whether willfully or maliciously " as if they were different: subdisjunctive, making
it to signify "wilfully i.e. maliciously; as if they were the same. Now neither is "willfully" the same as "maliciously"
nor will it do instead of it. We have already Frequently have we seen these pleonastic exerescencies, in a variety of instances , a desease: we
may now behold them a deadly poison. The workman who removes then several erections here specified in order to put
up new, does it "willfully" unless he does it in his sleep.

[... By day or night ... O.] At one 1 o'clock and or two 2 o'clock: at 1/2 an hour after 5, 3 or at 3/4 of an hour after] ...
In hot weather and in cold: in wet weather and in dry ... I know how this came to be just here, but itis so plain
that it has no business here, that the reason is not worth mentioning.

It were uncandid in one to insinuate, (for assuredly I do not believe) that the life of any man innocent in the eyes of
the framers of this clause stands by virtue in consequence of it in any real danger: but the very appearance, tho' it be but an
appearance of a danger of this sort impending over the innocent, is alarming and unseemly. To see a man being
out in a cage from the top of a precapeice high tower could not but cause make a man of a sensible frame of mind to shuddr; not
And who can answr for the effect of such a clause upon an ignorant mechanic under the propensity so common and so fashionable in the lower rank of man to make a bugbear of the law/ withstanding any security the strength of the tackle might afford his judgment against any probability of a fall.
[.... By authority of Parliament...O.] Weighing-Engines it seems that are on a road, must have been erected n by authority
of Parliament: as for "Turnpike-gates", it's no matter how they come there.

{...or shall forcibly rescue any person or persons, being lawfully in custody of any officer or other person for any
of the offences beforementioned ... O.] All this, as to any good purpose it can have, is just as much as comes to nothing;
<note> + See the authorities cited in Burn's Just. Tit. RESCUE. N/note>the same provision having been made of old in all cases of felony by the Common Law + unless it meant in this oblique
manner to make this accessory offence triable independently of the principal: which effect, whether it were designed,
or whether it would take place if it was designed, is more than I would venture to affirm or prophecy.

[...Beforementioned....O.] Where beforementioned ? 'In this Section'- it will readily be answered. But unhappily
there is no such thing as this Section or as any Section in a Statute, as we have before observed. Under this disadvantage,
the word [such] would have been preferable to [beforementioned]: because the application of the former is naturally
confined to the last subject matter assumed; whereas the latter stretches over the whole Instrument.

[...Shall be deemed & c.... N.]

---page break---

Identifier: | JB/079/136/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 79.
Date_1		Marginal Summary Numbering
Box	079	Main Headings
Folio number	136	Info in main headings field	sect. xii persons at large
Image	001	Titles
Category	text sheet	Number of Pages	1
Recto/Verso	recto	Page Numbering
Penner	jeremy bentham	Watermarks	[[watermarks::[gr with crown motif] [lion with vryheyt motif]]]
Marginals		Paper Producer
Corrections		Paper Produced in Year
Notes public		ID Number	25578
Box Contents