★ Find a new page to transcribe in our list of Untranscribed Manuscripts
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
<head>Peines Paley's Net</head><!-- headings in pencil --> | <head>Peines Paley's Net</head><!-- headings in pencil --> | ||
<p | <p>Moral and <gap/> <unclear>proper</unclear> <unclear>in</unclear> <hi rend="underline"><gap/></hi> <gap/> in punishment<lb/> | ||
Paley | Paley a Utilitarian - a <unclear>futile</unclear> <gap/> -<lb/> | ||
<hi rend="underline">Fisher of men</hi><lb/> | <hi rend="underline">Fisher of men</hi><lb/> | ||
Practise first, reason afterwards.</p> | |||
<p><note><!-- note in pencil -->1 Per Paley. Policy of English law to sweep all into a net & then make selections for punishment</note> | <p><note><!-- note in pencil -->1 Per Paley. Policy of English law to sweep all into a net & then make selections for punishment</note><lb/> | ||
"The <hi rend="underline">law</hi> of England", <add>(continues the Reverend Doctor)</add> is <hi rend="underline">constructed</hi> upon a different<lb/> | "The <hi rend="underline">law</hi> of England", <add>(continues the Reverend Doctor)</add> is <hi rend="underline">constructed</hi> upon a different<lb/> | ||
"and a <hi rend="underline">better</hi> policy. By the <hi rend="underline">numbers</hi> of statutes<lb/> | "and a <hi rend="underline">better</hi> policy. By the <hi rend="underline">numbers</hi> of statutes<lb/> | ||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
but when the execution<lb/> | but when the execution<lb/> | ||
of this sentence comes to be <hi rend="underline">deliberated</hi> upon, <hi rend="superscript">+</hi> | of this sentence comes to be <hi rend="underline">deliberated</hi> upon, <hi rend="superscript">+</hi> | ||
<note><hi rend="superscript">+</hi> without | <note><hi rend="superscript">+</hi> without expressible reasons</note><lb/> | ||
"a small proportion of each class is singled out, the<lb/> | "a small proportion of each class is singled out, the<lb/> | ||
"<hi rend="underline">general</hi> character, or the <unclear>peculiar</unclear> aggravations of whose<lb/> | "<hi rend="underline">general</hi> character, or the <unclear>peculiar</unclear> aggravations of whose<lb/> | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
<p><note><!-- note in pencil -->2 Erroniousness <add><del>& mis</del></add> & mischievousness of this doctrine 1. In 9 out of 10 cases it gives the King a dispensing power</note> | <p><note><!-- note in pencil -->2 Erroniousness <add><del>& mis</del></add> & mischievousness of this doctrine 1. In 9 out of 10 cases it gives the King a dispensing power</note> | ||
<lb/> | |||
1. The <hi rend="underline">law</hi> of England indeed! <add>forsooth.</add> <del>Thus</del> <add>In this <unclear>time</unclear> the law, but in another</add> According<lb/> | 1. The <hi rend="underline">law</hi> of England indeed! <add>forsooth.</add> <del>Thus</del> <add>In this <unclear>time</unclear> the law, but in another</add> According<lb/> | ||
to his own account of the matter, in nine instances<lb/> | to his own account of the matter, in nine instances<lb/> | ||
out of ten, <add>a power -</add> a <hi rend="underline">dispensing</hi> power exercised by the King<lb/> | out of ten, <add>a power -</add> a <hi rend="underline">dispensing</hi> power exercised by the King<lb/> | ||
over the law: and such an exercise of dispensing<lb/> | over the law: and such an exercise of dispensing<lb/> | ||
power eulogized <del>by</del> <add>under</add> the name <hi rend="underline">policy</hi> - "the <hi rend="underline">better</hi>" of | power eulogized <del>by</del> <add>under</add> the name <hi rend="underline">policy</hi> - "the <hi rend="underline">better</hi>" of them<lb/> | ||
his only policies he knew of <add><gap/> by him under that name</add> — <add>in a word</add> the <hi rend="underline">best</hi> policy -<lb/> | his only policies he knew of <add><gap/> by him under that name</add> — <add>in a word</add> the <hi rend="underline">best</hi> policy -<lb/> | ||
and of all laws [this dispensing power]<!-- brackets added in pencil --> the policy of the<lb/> | and of all laws [this dispensing power]<!-- brackets added in pencil --> the policy of the<lb/> | ||
| Line 39: | Line 40: | ||
<p>Will but <hi rend="underline">pardon</hi> (says somebody) you yourself approve: -<lb/> | <p>Will but <hi rend="underline">pardon</hi> (says somebody) you yourself approve: -<lb/> | ||
you yourself approved | you yourself approved but now of pardon - and<lb/> | ||
having approved it under one name, is it for you<lb/> | having approved it under one name, is it for you<lb/> | ||
to turn | to turn short round and condemn it under another?</p> | ||
<!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | <!-- DO NOT EDIT BELOW THIS LINE --> | ||
{{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | {{Metadata:{{PAGENAME}}}} | ||
Jany 1809 s4 1) Peines Paley's Net
Moral and proper in in punishment
Paley a Utilitarian - a futile -
Fisher of men
Practise first, reason afterwards.
1 Per Paley. Policy of English law to sweep all into a net & then make selections for punishment
"The law of England", (continues the Reverend Doctor) is constructed upon a different
"and a better policy. By the numbers of statutes
"creating capital offences, it sweeps into the net every
"crime, which under any possible circumstances may
"merit the punishment of death - +
+ Each statute specifies itself the very circumstances in which the supposed new demand for death is grounded.
but when the execution
of this sentence comes to be deliberated upon, +
+ without expressible reasons
"a small proportion of each class is singled out, the
"general character, or the peculiar aggravations of whose
"crimes, render them fit examples of public justice".
Thus far again the Reverend Doctor. So many
have so many errors: and every error mischievous.
2 Erroniousness & mis & mischievousness of this doctrine 1. In 9 out of 10 cases it gives the King a dispensing power
1. The law of England indeed! forsooth. Thus In this time the law, but in another According
to his own account of the matter, in nine instances
out of ten, a power - a dispensing power exercised by the King
over the law: and such an exercise of dispensing
power eulogized by under the name policy - "the better" of them
his only policies he knew of by him under that name — in a word the best policy -
and of all laws [this dispensing power] the policy of the
line of England!
Will but pardon (says somebody) you yourself approve: -
you yourself approved but now of pardon - and
having approved it under one name, is it for you
to turn short round and condemn it under another?
|
Identifier: | JB/107/214/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 107. |
|||
|---|---|---|---|
|
1809-01 |
1-2 |
||
|
107 |
law versus arbitrary power (a hatchet for dr paley's net) |
||
|
214 |
peines paley's net |
||
|
001 |
|||
|
text sheet |
1 |
||
|
recto |
e13 |
||
|
jeremy bentham |
|||
|
35205 |
|||
