JB/096/129/001

Click Here To Edit

of Truth.

I think it will not need many words to shew that these pleasures, great and real as they are, (or, to speak more accurately sources of pleasure,) depend as entirely upon the pleasures of the body, as those which he has allow'd to do so.

"As for Justice", continues he very candidly, I don't know very well what to make of it, that's true. Indeed it is not necessary. "All that is necessary to mean, and all I mean by the practise of it, is, the fulfilling what a man imagines to be his duty, be it what it may.

"No more is it necessary to give an exact definition here, of Truth. All I mean by view of truth is, that perception which a man experiences when he is satisfied
---page break---
with the evidence with which things appear to him."

For precision sake I will take his definitions instead of the terms defined: and begin with the pleasure which a man feels at fulfilling what he thinks his duty.

This fulfilling what he thinks his duty is either the doing of some act which he thinks it his duty to do, or the abstaining from some act, which he thinks it his duty to abstain from.

I will take an example from each branch of duty, Private and Public: and inquire whether the pleasure a man has from each of them, does not as much require the existence of the pleasures of the body, as any other does.

To begin with a duty of the Private kind. It is a duty in a man to behave with affection to his
---page break---
wife, and that in preference to any other woman. The man I take for my example,[?] is of that opinion[?]. Preferring her society to that of any other woman, he goes on partaking with her, amongst others, of those physical pleasures, which to partake of with another woman, [without her consent,] would be breach of duty to her. Thus far, I suppose there is none of that pleasure which consists in the fulfilling of what a man imagines to be his duty, and which has nothing to do, says our Author with the pleasures of the body. The pleasure which a man reaps in repeating an act, must be that which is all along the motive with him to that act. It is too absurd to think of any other motive for the act we are speaking of, than
---page break---
the pleasure which a man would find in it and which men did find in it, before any such word, or such a notion as that of duty came into their heads.

We now suppose him under a temptation to enter into the same course of pleasure with another woman, and he resists it. He has a desire to enjoy it, but notwithstanding he abstains. Now he has the pleasure of fulfilling his duty; of abstaining from what it is his duty to abstain from.

I should be glad now to know wherein the pleasure he now has consists. It consists not I suppose in the mere consciousness that he is abstaining that he is /that he is/ not doing what by this supposition he would take a pleasure in doing: what he has a desire to do: in short in the being under restraint: one might as well lay it down as a general maxim that a man finds a pleasure in thinking that he is going to prison.

Maupertuis

Identifier: | JB/096/129/001"JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 96.
Date_1		Marginal Summary Numbering
Box	096	Main Headings	legislation
Folio number	129	Info in main headings field	maupertuis ii
Image	001	Titles
Category	text sheet	Number of Pages	1
Recto/Verso	recto	Page Numbering	f1 / f2 / f3 / f4
Penner	jeremy bentham	Watermarks	[[watermarks::gr [crown motif] [britannia with shield motif]]]
Marginals		Paper Producer
Corrections		Paper Produced in Year
Notes public		ID Number	31133
Box Contents