JB/011/029/001

Click Here To Edit

1829. Aug. 20. 4

Reformists reviewed G.B.

Brougham
1. Imperfections
Partial Legislation acceded
to

1. p.1.
"Principles and practice"
Brougham division
of the subject matter of his
speech.

2. p.1.
Fundamental principle
laid down at the
close of his speech —
No partial legislation.

3. p.1.
This the principle
laid down by J.B. in
his Codification Proposal.

4. p.1.
Brougham's concluding
motion accordant
with that principle.

5. p.2.
By Mr. Brougham in
his speech all comprehensiveness
of reform
urged partial legislation
reprobated. Yet
after his speech a Commission
with limited
powers appointed
with his assent.

6. p.2.
This amendment of Peel's
whereby all-comprehensiveness
impossiblised
adopted on a
motion from Brougham.

7. p.3.
This fundamental principle
in the scale of aptitude
preceded by nothing
but J.B.'s contained
in Codification
Proposal.

8. p.3.
True that under matchless
constitution
Brougham's plan
must have become a
sole but still though
not the best it would
have been the next best.

---page break---

9. p.3.
By Peel's amendment
all comprehensiveness
impossiblized.

10. p.4.
In Brougham's speech
the principle not laid
down till the end —
contravened in the
first page.

11. p.4.
So in page 2 Equity
law excluded form
the inquiry.

12. p.4.
Nothing can be done
to any good purpose
in Common law
without the like
operation in Equity.

13. p.4.
This inseparability
well understood by
Eldon when by
Peel's mouth he forced
the separation of
Common Law & Real
Property Commissions
from Equity
Commission.

14. p.5.
Brougham's eyes
directed by a vision
of the Rolls.

15. p.5.
The bait unsuccessful
if it had been
otherwise Brougham's
tongue would have
been reduced to a
state of quiescence
as to law reform.

16. p.6.
Under matchless constitution
no alternative
to members
of Hon. House but
to do mischief or
nothing.

---page break---

17. p.6.
This it is ex vinculis

18. p.6.
Inseparability between
the several parts of
law the same as the
inseparability of flesh
& blood as per Portia
in the Merchant
of Venice.

19. p.7.
To J.B. no such
setters — To no Rolls
looks he no Court
butter for his bread.

Identifier: | JB/011/029/001 "JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 11.
Date_1	1829-08-20	Marginal Summary Numbering	1-19
Box	011	Main Headings	law amendment
Folio number	029	Info in main headings field	reformists reviewed
Image	001	Titles
Category	marginal summary sheet	Number of Pages	1
Recto/Verso	recto	Page Numbering	d4 / e1
Penner	george bentham	Watermarks	b&m 1829
Marginals		Paper Producer	arthur moore; richard doane
Corrections	jeremy bentham	Paper Produced in Year	1829
Notes public		ID Number	3726
Box Contents