JB/118/235/004

Click Here To Edit

20 Jany 1812
Panopticon – Holford's Report

1
1. No notice taken of
the difference in point
of expence.

2.
2. That plan which is
beyond comparison
most expensive is
reported as being to
be absolutely adopted –
to the less expensive
on the benefit of a
trial is refused.

3
Newspapers mentioned
slightingly by Holford as the only
trusted to by
J.B. But all the
others that can apply
to the mode, are
equally applicable
to J.B.s besides
those that are peculiar
to his.

4
Absolute rejection of
J.B.s plan contended
for, Those because
those are afraid of the
competition. Bell and
Lancaster for so much J.B.s wishes.
To give room for the
theory fallacy,
J.B.s plan kept from
being brought into .

7
For the purpose of
the House to the
breast of faith, liberality
of the intended
will be trumpeted.
But of the expence of it
be upon thence
being a needless expence
than for the purpose of it will be reduced.

---page break---

8
Holfords two Oracles
. If their
authority were not relied
upon no use expences any
more effected by them:
But their authority is his
sole reliance.

9.
They were
role, theirs
was examination in itself
J.B.s preference a cross-examination.

10
could not brook that
his should be countervailed
upon. He knows
little of human nature
of who thinks that of the
everythings that can be
done by love of money
there is everything that
can not be done by love
of power.

11
J.B. wishes for nothing
but competition. Nothing
will satisfy or
but exclusive
preference – monopoly

12
In J.B.s estimate of
the public time will
by the competition, i.e.
by the expence of
& part of it –
to J.B. has everything
to gain by it.

13
In case of J.B.s
plan having a trial
no possibility of want
of Inspectors, while
and live.

---page break---

14
Topics1. Finance Rep. 1797-8
favourable.
2. Competition – nothing
would please J.B. better.
Exclusive possession is the
aim of the other side.
3. It was for fear of
the comparison that
J.B.s plan was kept
back by the D. of Portland
in cooperation with
&c.
4. On the quantity of
land as yet unpurchased much reliance
as an objection. J.B.
would give up his claim
to it.
5. Nothing a stronger condemnation
in Pitt
&c personal for
Refer 9 years
the number deaths.
6. Objection. In the
open Panopticon mode
nobody will care about
it so as to afford inspection. Answer.
and will at any
rate.

---page break---

(Debates 18 Jany 1812
or thereabouts). These
makes a merit of getting
the honest poor to feed
on fish and potatoes
without bread. In Panopt.
J.B. was forced
to engage to give bread and
meat: and p. 47
makes a point and a
of the authority that convicts
will be fed with"the best
bread" the best meat
the best of everything else
that is to be had in the
market.

☞ What J.B. contends
for is – not to be absolutely
proscribed.
He will divide the
land – give half to
& .
They will inspect
: and let them
be inspections.
But inspection is what they

Propose that the
measure should form be not concluded
upon till
the comparative expence
be of the building be
ascertained: viz. not
by estimate, but
by actual contract.

and
propose not any Subsidiary Establishment.
J.B. being it is objected
proposes only his own.
But for objective that
will be even too great
viz. by the of
his gain.

Put it to them whether
they have read J.B.s
as well as and
evidence?

Identifier: | JB/118/235/004 "JB/" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 118.
Date_1	1812-01-20	Marginal Summary Numbering	1-14
Box	118	Main Headings	panopticon
Folio number	235	Info in main headings field	panopticon halford's report
Image	004	Titles
Category	marginal summary sheet	Number of Pages	2
Recto/Verso	recto	Page Numbering
Penner	jeremy bentham	Watermarks	th 1806
Marginals		Paper Producer	andre morellet
Corrections		Paper Produced in Year	1806
Notes public		ID Number	39289
Box Contents